Understanding Your Role in Choir Dynamics: When to Stay and When to Go

As a musician, particularly a vocalist in a choir or ensemble, the balance between performance and listening is critical. However, the question of whether to stay or leave a choir based on the perceived value or contributions of other members is a common yet complex challenge.

The Nuance of Choir Participation

Being a part of a choir involves more than just stepping in and singing. It's an experience that requires attention, dedication, and the ability to listen and adapt. Choirs, whether church or community-based, are built on mutual respect and shared goals. Singing during a performance is not just an expression of individual skill but a contribution to the overall harmony and cohesiveness of the group.

Listening and Performing

Listening and performing simultaneously are both essential aspects of being a vocalist in a choir. Moments in rehearsal may require the entire group to pause and learn, enhancing the overall performance quality. However, during a performance, the focus should be on delivering a cohesive and powerful sound. Occasions where sound production has to stop, such as a vocalist swallowing saliva, are rare but important instances that require the rest of the group to cohesively adjust.

The Decisions To Stay or Leave

Deciding to leave or stay in a choir is a deeply personal choice that should not be influenced by external perceptions. Sometimes, individuals might feel that they are too good or too bad for the choir, which is a form of narcissism. It is crucial to make a decision based on your own reasons and to stick to it.

Commitment and Integrity

Joining a group like a choir is a commitment. You make a decision to join, and you should stick with it through the toughest and most inconvenient times. Commitment means enduring the group's ups and downs until the end of the season. After that, you have the freedom to choose whether to continue or not. Avoid the trap of entering and exiting the group frequently, hoping to influence its dynamics.

Strategic Timing

When leaving the choir, timing is crucial. Quitting during a crucial period can have significant consequences. For example, leaving during a national competition or an important performance not only risks the group's reputation but also involves the loss of financial and time investments made by the group members.

Impact on the Choir

Consider the impact of your departure on the choir. If you leave in the off-season, like June or January, your decision might not be noticed. However, leaving during a high-pressure period, such as the week before a significant performance, can be detrimental to the group's morale and success. Making such a hasty decision can be seen as disrespectful to the group's efforts and goals.

The Reflection on "Devaluating Selves"

The phrase "They are devaluing themselves" often reflects more on the individual making the statement than on the choir members. It is important to evaluate your own behavior and decisions rather than assuming that others are devaluing themselves.

Conclusion

Deciding to stay or leave a choir is a personal choice. Make your decision based on your own reasons and stick to it. If you commit to a choir, be there for the entire commitment period. Timing is crucial, and your departure has a significant impact on the group. Reflect on your own actions and decisions rather than judging others. By doing so, you contribute positively to the choir's harmony and success.