Narrative of Controversies Surrounding NCT: Cultural Appropriation and Misappropriation
NCT (Neo Culture Technology) is a prominent K-pop group known for its diverse and extensive lineup. However, the journey of NCT is not without controversy. This article delves into some of the significant scandals that the group, under SM Entertainment, has faced over the years. These include cultural appropriation and misappropriation, member controversies, training and treatment, and fan interactions. Additionally, it explores how NCT has been affected by lineup changes and online backlash.
Cultural Appropriation in NCT
NCT has experienced fierce criticism regarding instances of cultural appropriation in their music and performances. This often involves the group using elements from various cultures without proper context or respect. For instance, their music videos and performances have been criticized for lacking cultural sensitivity. One specific instance that garnered significant attention was the Devil Performance. The song 'Victimae Paschali Laudes' was used in a performance, which participants found disrespectful, especially given the religious and cultural context of the song. The lyrics and theme of the song are deeply rooted in Catholicism, and its use in a performance heavily thematic in devil imagery was seen as out of place and disrespectful.
The Devil Performance Controversy
In the Devil Performance, Ten (a member of NCT) performed to a hallowed Christian song, 'Victimae Paschali Laudes,' which is traditionally used in Catholic Holy Communion. Despite being a Buddhist, Ten performed the sign of the cross during the performance, drawing more criticism. The handling of this incident by agencies like SM Entertainment and Mnet was minimal. This highlights the notion that actions are often taken only when protests by Kitive (K-pop Netizens) are viral or significant enough to warrant attention.
Community Reactions
There is a notable lack of support from K-pop netizens who, due to their predominantly atheist, Buddhist, or Protestant backgrounds, might not have a high level of awareness about the cultural significance of the song. The article emphasizes the author's stance as a devoted Catholic who found the use of the song disrespectful. The author calls for actions to be taken, requesting information on how to contact SM Entertainment to address the issue.
Other Controversies Surrounding NCT
In addition to cultural appropriation, NCT members have faced personal controversies. Lucas' temporary hiatus from the group in 2020 after accusations of inappropriate behavior and communication with fans is just one of these incidents. There have also been discussions about the rigorous training and treatment of trainees in the K-pop industry, including members of NCT. Fans have raised concerns about the mental and physical toll on idols during their training period and early careers. Fan interactions with NCT members have also led to backlash, with some fans expressing dissatisfaction regarding how certain members engage with fans or handle fan events.
Lineup Changes and Fan Dissatisfaction
The rotating lineup of NCT has occasionally led to dissatisfaction among fans, particularly when members they support are sidelined or when new members are introduced. This dynamic can create a sense of instability and unpredictability for the fans who have grown attached to certain members. The ever-changing lineup adds another layer of complexity to the group's management and fan relationship.
Online Backlash and Mental Health Considerations
Like many K-pop groups, NCT has faced online backlash and criticism from so-called 'anti-fans.' Additionally, idols in the K-pop industry often experience intense scrutiny and public pressure. This can have a detrimental impact on their mental health and well-being.
Conclusion
While these scandals have generated significant discussion and debate, they also highlight the intense scrutiny that K-pop idols face in the public eye. NCT, like other K-pop groups, has navigated a challenging path of balancing artistic expression and cultural sensitivity while maintaining high standards of performance and public behavior. These controversies serve as a reminder of the multifaceted nature of the K-pop industry and the broader issues surrounding cultural representation in entertainment.