Music Critics: A Beacon or a Luxury?
Do music critics serve a purpose in today's digital age, where streaming services allow listeners to discover new music easily? Some might argue that their influence is negligible, while others believe that their insights provide valuable guidance. In this article, we delve into the role of music critics and the value they bring to the music community.
The Changing Landscape of Music Discovery
In the era of free listening, the importance of music critics seems to be diminishing. With the advent of streaming platforms, users can sample entire albums for free before making a purchasing decision. Therefore, the need to rely on a critic's opinion, often for a nominal time investment, is becoming less evident. The role of critics today is more about helping listeners make informed financial decisions, much like choosing a restaurant or a movie.
The Infallibility of Man's Hearing
Many have turned away from relying on music critics, preferring instead to form their own opinions. Personally, I have paid little heed to music critics as I enjoy listening and judging for myself. There have been no instances where their comments or reviews significantly influenced my musical choices or preferences. The notable exception was the late John Peel, whose late-night radio show provided insightful and thought-provoking content.
The Function of Criticism in Music
Despite my personal indifference towards critics, it is undeniable that music criticism plays a crucial role in our society. Music transcends the auditory; it is imbued with spiritual, social, and political significance. The act of listening, being affected by the music, and discussing it provides a platform for critical thinking and social growth. When we engage in dialogue about what we hear, we ensure that our experiences are more than just mindless consumerism.
Agreement and Disagreement: The Fuel of Thought
Just because one does not agree with every review or critique does not mean they lack value. Disagreement, in fact, can be a catalyst for deeper reflection and better understanding. Each critique, regardless of whether we agree with it, can spark more thorough and nuanced thinking. A prime example is the first edition of The Rolling Stone Record Guide that I read in my teenage years. The harsh ratings for early Black Sabbath albums prompted me to question my own judgments and evaluate the source of the review. This process of self-questioning and critical evaluation enhances our understanding and strengthens our own thoughts and opinions.
Music as the Spiritual Avant-Garde
Music is far more than mere entertainment; it is a form of spiritual expression, preceding philosophy and rational thinking. It is the avant-garde in spiritual expression, and as such, we must engage with it thoughtfully. If musicians take the trouble to express humanity in deeply meaningful ways, it is a bare minimum for us as listeners to listen and contribute our thoughts. Becoming a music critic, then, is a responsibility to practice and deepen this engagement. Do not shy away from the industry-backed or sensationalist publications; instead, find and participate in the real, substantive conversations. The insights and opinions from true critics can enrich our understanding of music and its impact on our lives.
Conclusion
Music criticism, while not a necessity for everyone, can be a valuable tool for deepening our engagement with music. Whether it challenges our preconceptions or affirms our choices, it plays a pivotal role in the metaphysical, social, and philosophical enrichment of our lives. If you are passionate about music and can write about it, consider becoming a music critic and contributing to the conversations that shape our understanding of music's profound impact.