Merging Marvel and DC: The Pros and Cons of a Shared Universe

There has been a lot of discussion and debate around the idea of Marvel and DC merging their universes. The question is: would it be a good thing or a bad thing? In this article, we'll explore the potential benefits and drawbacks of a shared universe and offer our perspective on the matter.

The Case Against a Shared Universe

While a crossover between the two companies with a few characters can be intriguing, trying to mix the entire two universes together would not be ideal. Marvel and DC have different vibes: Marvel heroes are humans trying to be gods, while DC characters are gods trying to act human. This difference in tone and style would need to be delicately balanced to maintain the integrity of each universe.

One potential issue is the sheer number of characters from both companies. If Marvel and DC were to merge, there could be a surplus of heroes in one universe, resulting in over-saturation and diminishing the impact of each character. Another issue is the merging of divine beings from various mythologies. The Norse Gods, for example, are mortal and are destined to die in Ragnarok. Similarly, the Greek and Norse gods from DC and Marvel need to be reconciled in terms of their power levels, personalities, and mythological roles. These are some of the biggest problems that would need to be addressed.

Adapting Marvel's Squadron Supreme to the 616 Universe

Instead of merging the entire universes, a better option would be to adapt Marvel's Squadron Supreme into the 616 Marvel Universe. The Squadron Supreme is Marvel's version of the Justice League, and seeing a universe where the Avengers, X-Men, the Fantastic Four, and the Squadron Supreme are all in one shared universe would be a fascinating concept. This could serve as a blueprint for a shared universe if it ever needs to happen in the future.

The Potential Benefits of a Shared Universe

Assuming that both companies can overcome the challenges mentioned above, the benefits of a merged universe are numerous. With a combined team of powerful heroes and skilled writers, we could see better comics and movies. For example, Batman and Captain America could team up to save the world, using their respective strengths to tackle different challenges. Additionally, the coordination of heroes like Thor, Hulk, Superman, and Wonder Woman could create an impressive dynamic. The unity of characters like Flash and Spider-Man in a shared universe would also be exciting to see. Their bond over chemistry and togetherness could lead to some memorable in-universe collaborations.

Conclusion

The idea of merging Marvel and DC could be exciting, but it would require careful consideration and execution. If done right, a shared universe could bring together a powerhouse of heroes and allow the best of both worlds to shine. However, it's important to keep the unique qualities and dynamics of each universe intact. Until then, both Marvel and DC can continue to offer their distinct and compelling stories in their existing universes.