Legolas: Cornerstone of the Fellowship in Tolkien's Universe
If Legolas were not a character, would J.R.R. Tolkien have created another character to take his place in supporting Aragorn? Or would Aragorn have been left alone during the perilous journey? This article explores these possibilities and the unique role Legolas plays in the Fellowship of the Ring.
Why Glorfindel Was Not the Choice
Initially, Tolkien considered having Glorfindel accompany the Fellowship as the spiritual and powerful representative of the elves. However, his decision to include Legolas, a lesser but capable Woodland Prince, serves a more strategic purpose. Glorfindel, with his divine powers, would have compromised the secret nature of the Fellowship's mission. The presence of such a figure would have made the endeavor less covert and discreet, undermining its greatest strength.
Legolas, while not nearly as powerful as Glorfindel, still brings a unique perspective and skill set to the group. His keen senses, lightness, and the bonds he shares with other elves add layers to the Fellowship's dynamics and complement the overall narrative.
Purpose of Sending Legolas to Rivendell
Legolas' presence in Rivendell is a strategic move. After Gollum's capture, Gandalf and Aragorn requested King Thranduil to keep him in custody. However, when Gollum escaped, Thranduil sent his son to warn Eldirond and Aragorn. This was not merely a practical measure but a symbolic one. It implied a deep regret on the part of Thranduil, hinting at the betrayal of trust, which Legolas might interpret as a moral obligation to join the Fellowship. Despite the overwhelming presence of elves in Rivendell, including many more powerful and experienced ones, Legolas' inclusion was a deliberate choice by Tolkien to maintain the dynamics of the Fellowship and the secrecy of their mission.
The Role of a Secretive Team
The Fellowship of the Ring operates on the premise of stealth and discretion. They move unnoticed and avoid unnecessary battles, only engaging in conflict as a last resort. Having Glorfindel, a Balrog-slayer and a hero, in the Fellowship could have overshadowed the deeds of the others, including Aragorn, and compromised the secrecy of the mission. This is a critical point in the story, as the Fellowship's success depends on their ability to remain concealed and avoid drawing unnecessary attention. Including a hero like Glorfindel would have detracted from the Fellowship's covert nature and strategic advantage.
Conclusion and Final Thoughts
While varying choices in the composition of the Fellowship might have altered the course of the story, Legolas remains an integral and indispensable character. His presence enhances the depth and complexity of the narrative, maintaining the secrecy and strategic essence of the Fellowship's journey. Whether Glorfindel or another character was the original choice, Legolas ultimately serves as the perfect representation of the elves and the Woodland Kingdom, playing a crucial role in supporting Aragorn and the Fellowship's mission.