Legitimizing Gendry: A Fan-Theorized Scenario in Game of Thrones
"What if Daenerys Targaryen legitimizes Gendry and makes him Lord of Storms End?" is a fan-spodulated question that examines the hypothetical scenario within the fictional world of Game of Thrones. This article explores the possible outcomes and the implications of such a decision, delving into the lore, characters, and the broader narrative of Westeros.
Introduction to the Scenario
The question posed reflects the current state of the show: Daenerys Targaryen, the Dragon Queen, is facing immense challenges, particularly health-wise, while Gendry, a member of the Brotherhood without Banners, is far removed from the political center of power.
The Strategic Implications of Legitimizing Gendry
If Daenerys Targaryen were to legitimize Gendry, the move would have multiple strategic implications:
Heir to the Iron Throne: Legitimizing Gendry would make him a legitimate heir to the Iron Throne, providing an alternative to Joffrey, Tommen, and Myrcella Baratheon, who were never legitimate due to their father's declining legitimacy.
Lord of Storms End: Nominating Gendry as Lord of Storms End, one of the key castles in the North, would strengthen Daenerys's position in Westeros. Storms End's control is crucial for securing the Targaryen claim to the throne.
Leadership of the Brotherhood without Banners: Assuming Gendry is alive and in a position to accept the title, he could take charge of the Brotherhood without Banners, making them a powerful force to reckon with.
Political Loyalty: Legitimizing Gendry would likely gain the support of the North, especially if he is seen as a clear and present challenge to the Lannisters and other southern houses.
Risk and Realism: Feasibility of the Scenario
The feasibility of this scenario is highly dependent on several factors:
Surviving Combat: Both Daenerys and Gendry are in precarious positions. Daenerys is suffering from heavy illnesses in the Dothraki Sea, while Gendry is in the Riverlands, which are under intense conflict.
Political Support: Even if Gendry were to become legitimised, the post-war political landscape could be vastly different. The show hints at the possibility of a fragmented Westeros, where powerful families may be reduced to mere remnants, or small kingdoms rise from the ashes.
Legitimising Authority: For Gendry to be legitimised, the entity holding the authority to do so (likely Daenerys) needs to survive and have the power to make such a decision. Given the current dire situations described, this is not guaranteed.
Contemporary Commentary and Fan Reception
Given the current state of the show, fans are divided on the likelihood of Gendry's legitimisation and ultimate survival. Some consider it a plausible scenario, while others believe it is highly improbable:
Feasible Legitimation: Some fans believe Jon Snow, as the legitimate heir to House Stark, might legitimise Gendry upon his return to the North. Gendry, being a Baratheon bastard, would be of royal blood, making him a strong contender.
Survival Uncertainty: Many fans also express doubt over Gendry's survival, citing the intense battles and overall chaos in Westeros. If the human population is significantly reduced, the traditional political structures might crumble, making legitimisation less relevant.
Conclusion
While the hypothetical scenario of legitimizing Gendry and making him Lord of Storms End presents an interesting storyline, it is heavily contingent upon numerous factors that may not all come together as envisioned. The story of Game of Thrones delves into complex realms of politics, survival, and the resilience of humanity, making such scenarios both plausible and highly speculative within the show's universe.