Is Rey the True Chosen One in the Star Wars Franchise?

The concept of the 'True Chosen One' in the Star Wars franchise has been a recurring theme throughout the nine movies. Fans have often debated whether it is Anakin, Luke, Leia, or Rey who embodies the role of the chosen one. George Lucas firmly established that it was Anakin from the original trilogy, but how does the sequels influence this narrative?

Is the Concept of the Chosen One Consistent Across the Entire Franchise?

Deciding on the 'True Chosen One' isn't as straightforward as it may seem. In the sequel trilogy, the concept is contested. The groundwork laid by George Lucas in the original and prequel trilogies is starkly different from the aspirations of the sequel trilogy. George Lucas's vision was mainly rooted in storytelling and narrative coherence, unlike the sequels which seem more driven by commercial interests.

While Kathleen Kennedy, the producer of the sequel trilogy, aimed to empower female characters and address social justice issues, her interpretation of the 'chosen one' narrative lacks the legitimacy of Lucas's original vision. The sequel trilogy, in many ways, appears to be fan fiction, lacking the depth and authenticity that the original trilogy offered.

The Authorship and Authenticity of the Sequels

One cannot ignore the fundamental differences between the sequels and the original works. The prequels and the original trilogy were envisioned by George Lucas, with a comprehensive storytelling arc. The sequels, on the other hand, were driven by a desire to capitalize on the success of the franchise, often placing financial interests over narrative consistency.

The sequel trilogy's lack of proper resolution and coherence is deeply troubling for true fans of the franchise. The sudden introduction of Rey, the character with seemingly no background or backstory, and her rapid ascension to the status of the 'True Chosen One' feels forced and unnatural. Such a transformation would require a significant and well-expounded backstory, which the sequels fail to provide.

The True Chosen One: Luke Skywalker or Rey?

While Rey may claim the title of the 'True Chosen One,' it is hard to argue convincingly. Luke Skywalker, in the end, comes into his own as the true chosen one. He is the one who defeated Darth Vader and, ultimately, Emperor Palpatine, bringing balance to the Force. His journey demonstrates not only a personal transformation but also a pivotal moment in the franchise's narrative arc.

Moreover, if we accept the sequels as part of the official history of the franchise, the idea of an unfulfilled prophecy loses its validity. The concept of the 'Chosen One' appeared flawlessly realized with the destruction of Palpatine, but the absence of a defined, consistent narrative leaves many questions unanswered. Luke Skywalker's actions and motivations provide a clear and genuine connection to the final battle and the restoration of balance in the Force.

Conclusion

In the context of George Lucas's original vision, the concept of the 'True Chosen One' aligns with Luke Skywalker. The sequels, driven by commercial interests and differing creative visions, fail to capture the essence and narrative integrity of the original trilogy. While Rey's journey is compelling, the lack of a genuine and consistent background makes her claim to the title of 'True Chosen One' untenable.