Is Politeness or Political Correctness More Important in Society?
The question of whether politeness or political correctness came first is a timely one, especially in the current climate of heightened sensitivity and social divides. It is widely acknowledged that politeness has been a cornerstone of American behavior for a long time. However, with the emergence of a generation that shuns any negative input, political correctness was born.
Poised Between Tradition and Modernity
The roots of politeness can be traced back to the Greek word polis, meaning city. This concept of being courteous and considerate towards others is not a fleeting phenomenon but a deep-seated tradition that has shaped societal interactions. Historically, societies have revered individuals who exhibited certain traits, such as derring-do in ancient warriors, which were considered "politically correct" in their context. However, modern-day examples like vaccine opposition and mask debates reveal that political correctness can sometimes be more about rhetoric than reality.
Political Correctness and Its Critics
Political correctness is often seen as a tool for controlling the narrative. It seeks to redefine terms and labels to favor one perspective over another. This can be observed in the term "illegal aliens," which some refer to as "undocumented immigrants." This misnomer sidesteps the legal and logical definition, sparking a debate on accurate terminology. The insidious aspect of political correctness is its ability to derail genuine discussions by focusing on the words used rather than the substance of the argument. This leads to a narrowing of the discourse and can prevent meaningful progress.
The Value of Politeness in Society
As opposed to political correctness, politeness is a more fundamental and voluntary aspect of human interaction. It serves as the lubricant that keeps social relationships smooth and productive. Robert Heinlein's theory emphasizes the critical role of politeness in maintaining a healthy society. He believed that a culture's decline is often marked by a loss of manners and consideration for others. A society that lacks politeness risks descending into conflict, recriminations, and violence.
The Importance of Politeness Over Political Correctness
While political correctness can be essential in certain contexts, especially in fostering inclusivity and fairness, it is the inherent courtesy and respect towards others that truly underpin a functional and harmonious society. Heinlein's assertion that impoliteness is a symptom of a dying culture resonates with our current societal challenges. The combination of impoliteness and the politicization of everyday language has created a fertile ground for unrest and anarchy.
Ultimately, the emphasis should be on politeness as the bedrock of social interactions. While political correctness has its place, it should not overshadow the importance of genuine respect and consideration for others. In a world where words can influence perceptions and actions, maintaining a polite and considerate demeanor is crucial for fostering understanding and cooperation.
Conclusion
The balance between politeness and political correctness is crucial for societal progress. While political correctness can be a powerful tool in modern discussions, it should not overshadow the timeless value of politeness. By prioritizing politeness, we can create a more respectful and harmonious environment, fostering true understanding and progress.