This article explores the portrayal of kindness in Game of Thrones, examining whether it can be a weakness and if there are indeed other virtues that matter more. Through the analysis of key characters and plot points, we will delve into the role of kindness in the narrative and its contribution to the story's themes.
Introduction
The universe of Game of Thrones (GoT) is vast and complex, with ethical and moral quandaries that challenge its characters. Central to the series is the question of whether kindness is a weakness. This article will argue that while kindness can indeed be a tool for manipulation, it is not inherently weak. In fact, it is the combination of kindness with common sense, honor, and mercy that forms a strong foundation for enduring strength and loyalty.
The Role of Kindness in Game of Thrones
Kindness in the world of Game of Thrones is not a virtue that stands alone. It is often described as a tool that can be wielded for good or ill, depending on the context and execution. In many cases, a lack of common sense can turn acts of kindness into sources of vulnerability. However, when combined with wisdom, kindness becomes a powerful ally.
Evidencing Kindness as a Strength
1. Ned Stark: The Poster Child for Kindness
Ned Stark, despite his noble qualities, serves as a prime example of what happens when kindness is not coupled with common sense. His adherence to his principles often leaves him vulnerable, culminating in his execution. Nevertheless, his beliefs and actions continue to inspire fierce loyalty long after his death.
In the books, after Ned Stark is unjustly executed, his legacy lives on. The North maintains its loyalty to the Starks, even in the face of overwhelming obstacles. For instance, when Arya Stark is sent to marry Ramsay Bolton, the Lannisters try to use a fake Arya to claim Winterfell, but Northerners still risk their lives to rescue her, driven by their loyalty to Ned. This demonstrates that kind and honorable actions, even if they result in short-term losses, have lasting impacts.
Loyalty and the Impact of Virtues
2. The Power of Honor and Integrity
Honor and integrity, when backed by kindness, form a resilient foundation. Characters like Ned Stark and Robb Stark exemplify these virtues, inspiring loyalty that transcends their immediate circumstances. Even years after their deaths, the Starks’ beliefs and actions continue to ignite fierce loyalty among the Northerners.
Lord Wyman Manderly, in his speech from "A Dance with Dragons," speaks of the Red Wedding and his desire for revenge. "The North Remembers" highlights how the Starks' legacy manifests as a driving force for retribution. Lords like Wyman remember Ned and Robb, and this memory motivates their actions, contributing to the broader narrative of justice and revenge.
3. The North's Loyalist Actions
When Stannis Baratheon calls on the Northern houses to join his cause, 10-year-old Lyanna Mormont responds with "Bear Island knows no king but the King in the North whose name is Stark." Despite the risk of retaliation, Loyalty to Ned’s name continues to inspire action. This deep-seated respect and honor create a powerful sense of commitment, further emphasizing the importance of these virtues.
Consequences of a Lack of Kindness
4. The Fall of the Freys and House Bolton
In contrast, the Freys who lack honor and kindness face no such loyalty. When members of House Frey start disappearing or are killed by Arya, there is no uproar from other houses. Similarly, when Tywin Lannister is murdered, there is no demand for justice, as he inspires respect but not love or deep-seated loyalty.
When House Bolton is ultimately defeated, Sansa Stark encapsulates the sentiment that "Your words will disappear. Your house will disappear. Your name will disappear. All memory of you will disappear." This stark realization underscores the importance of enduring virtues like honor and kindness, which create lasting legacies.
The Final Message of Game of Thrones
The overarching message in Game of Thrones is not that kindness, honor, or mercy are inherently weaknesses. On the contrary, these virtues can be powerful strengths, especially when they are supported by common sense and integrity. While short-term victories might be won without these virtues, the long-term benefits of loyalty, respect, and dedication are undeniable.
In conclusion, Game of Thrones portrays kindness as a tool that, when coupled with wisdom and virtue, can lead to profound and lasting strength. The narrative emphasizes that true strength lies in the enduring impact of these values, rather than fleeting victories through manipulation or ruthlessness.