Is It Worth Watching Doctor Who Beyond Series 8? A Personal View

Doctor Who, a beloved science fiction series that has captivated audiences for decades, is known for its numerous storylines and beloved companions. But when it comes to the exploration after the Capaldi era (Series 8), opinions can vary. Specifically, viewers are divided on whether to continue with the 12th Doctor (played by Peter Capaldi). This article delves into the pros and cons, providing an honest look at the series.

Capaldi’s Doctor and the 12th Series

Upon the arrival of Peter Capaldi as the 12th Doctor, many fans were curious about their compatibility. My personal experience with the series suggested that Capaldi's Doctor was less engaging compared to previous Doctors, such as Matt Smith's Twelfth or Christopher Eccleston's Tenth. This did not match my expectations, given the high standard set by the Seventh Doctor (played by Sylvester McCoy), or Bill the companion who appeared in Series 10. However, it is important to note that attitudes towards the series can be highly subjective. Fan surveys often highlight that the last three episodes of Capaldi's run are considered the best ever, which may not align with my personal preferences.

The 13th Doctor and Jodie Whittaker

With the arrival of the 13th Doctor, played by Jodie Whittaker, the narrative took a new turn. Fans were initially apprehensive about her capabilities as a lead actress. While Jodie is indeed a talented actor, issues with the writing and the introduction of too many companions often received criticism. Many felt that the heavy themes were not explored adequately, leaving the narrative feeling disjointed. Despite these criticisms, the series' finale did feature the most beautifully tragic two-part episode, which many cherish.

Series 14 and 15: Back to RTD

Series 14 and 15 brought back the 9th and 10th Doctors, thanks to Russell T. Davies (RTD), who is known for his energetic storytelling and the revival of the series. For those who enjoyed the Ninth and Tenth Doctors, the later series might resonate well. The energy and fun that fans remember can be rekindled in these seasons, providing a refreshingly different experience.

The Importance of a Chance and Diversity

While personal preferences and experiences can greatly influence one's opinion on future episodes, it is essential to give the show a chance. Every Doctor has their own unique style and characteristics. The 12th Doctor's tenure, though less popular with some fans, includes a beautifully tragic episode that stands out. Similarly, the 13th Doctor, despite criticism, has a companion (Bill) who is one of the most beloved in recent memory. Furthermore, the introduction of a black lesbian companion is a step towards diversity in the show and showcases the evolving nature of the series.

Final Thoughts

In conclusion, while not everyone enjoys the same Doctor or companion, it is worth considering the broader context of the series. Each era of Doctor Who brings its unique set of experiences and memorable moments. The critical final episodes of the Capaldi era and the resurgence of energy in the RTD era suggest that the series is always evolving and worth investing time in to see what comes next.