Introduction

The long-standing question of Jon Snow's true parentage has captured the imaginations of fans worldwide. One of the more intriguing theories suggests that Ashara Dayne could be Jon's mother. This article delves into the timeline, potential connections, and evidence to explore the feasibility of this theory.

Timeline of Events

Ashara Dayne at Harrenhal: Ashara Dayne attended the tournament at Harrenhal in 281 AC, where the Targaryen family were present. Kidnapping of Lyanna Stark: Lyanna Stark was kidnapped by Rhaegar Targaryen in 280 AC, leading to the start of Robert's Rebellion. Birth of Jon Snow: Jon Snow was born shortly after the end of the rebellion, around 283 AC.

Ashara’s Fate

Ashara's storyline post-Harrenhal tournament is somewhat ambiguous. After witnessing the events surrounding the rebellion and the loss of her brother, Ser Arthur Dayne, her fate is unclear. Most notably, it is believed that she died by suicide around the same time Jon was born. This contradiction in timelines raises questions about whether Ashara could have had a child before her apparent demise.

Rhaegar and Lyanna

The evidence supporting Lyanna Stark as Jon's mother is strong. Key points include:

Branson's visions in the show revealing Jon's true parentage. Hints in the books suggesting a possible promise Rhaegar made to Lyanna as she lay dying.

Character Connections and Alternatives

Ashara's connections to several characters in the story, including Ned Stark and his family, complicate the theory. If Ashara were Jon's mother, it would require significant changes to the established relationships and motivations of these characters. However, an alternative theory proposes that Brandon Stark, rather than Ned, could be the father. This theory is based on the following points:

Ashara’s Attraction to Brandon: Brandon Stark was more likely a suitable candidate for Ashara given her history of falling in love with him at Harrenhal. Barristan's Perception of Starks: Barristan Selmy, who seemingly holds a grudge against the Starks, has no hatred toward Ned, showing a complexity in Brandon's relationship with the family. Timeline Alignment: Brandon's arrest and Ashara's subsequent actions create a plausible timeline where Jon could be born in 283 AC.

This alternative theory simplifies the timeline and aligns with the idea that Jon Snow could very well be Ashara Dayne's child.

Conclusion

While the theory that Ashara Dayne is Jon Snow's mother is intriguing, the established timeline and other evidence make it less likely compared to the theory of Lyanna Stark being his mother. However, the Brandon Stark theory offers a compelling alternative. Fans may have to wait until the next books or adaptation to uncover the truth about Jon Snow's parentage.

Further Reading and References

For further exploration of this topic, readers can refer to:

A Song of Ice and Fire series by George R.R. Martin, particularly AGiere's Game. for detailed timelines and character connections. Forums and fan discussions on the theory for additional insights.