Is 'This Is Us' the Most Overrated TV Show of 2023?

When it comes to television, what primarily defines it is the quality of storytelling, acting, and the emotional impact it has on viewers. However, the subjective opinion of what constitutes a 'good' or 'bad' show is highly personal. Some people might argue that 'This Is Us' suffers from a case of being too overrated.

Introduction to 'This Is Us'

'This Is Us' premiered in 2016 and has since become a sensation with its raw, emotional storytelling and relatable characters. The show, which centers on the Pearson family, takes on a delicate thread of challenging issues such as mental health, addiction, and loss, each episode weaving a complex web of intertwining plotlines.

The Overrated Contention

Many argue that the very thing that made 'This Is Us' watchable has also made it overrated. The show’s success lies in its ability to evoke deep emotional responses, but critics say this reliance on weepiness, emotional manipulation, and self-congratulation makes it borderline manipulative. This emotional manipulation may be effective in drawing in viewers, but it may also leave them feeling exhausted by the end of each episode.

Personal Opinions and Critiques

Personal taste is a significant factor in how a show is perceived. For example, one might argue that Steve Harvey, the host of the family feuds on NBC, is inherently disliked. There are criticisms circulating around that Steve Harvey’s presence on 'This Is Us' glorifies problematic behavior and contributes to a show that might just be too self-absorbed.

Another prime example is the phenomenally successful 'Family Feud', where Steve Harvey constantly refers to himself and his achievements, which a certain group of audience members find highly irritating. The show often turns into a self-indulgent showcase for Harvey, focusing more on his personal anecdotes than on the entertainment value of the game itself.

Comparisons with Other Lucrative Shows

Some viewers might favor shows that maintain a balance between emotional depth and entertainment value. Series like 'Stranger Things', 'The Mandalorian', or 'Cobra Kai' stand out with their compelling narratives, captivating visuals, and well-written characters. These shows manage to create a forfeiture in emotional investment without relying on excessive sentimentality, making them a better choice for viewers who prefer a more balanced viewing experience.

Conclusion: Is 'This Is Us' Truly Overrated?

The question of whether 'This Is Us' is overrated depends on individual taste. While some appreciate the raw, multifaceted portrayal of the Pearson family and the intricate emotional journeys they embarked upon, others find it too weepy, self-indulgent, and artificial. As with any critically acclaimed series, opinions vary widely, and the notion of a show being overrated is subjective and open to interpretation.

Ultimately, the enjoyment of a show lies in the viewer's ability to connect with the narrative and characters. If 'This Is Us' continues to find its audience, it’s clear that the emotional and relatable aspects of the show resonate with many. But for those who feel it has tilted too far into the realm of self-congratulation and over-sentimentality, it might be time to explore other options that offer a more balanced and engaging viewing experience.

Keywords: This Is Us, overrated TV shows, sentimental drama