Exploring Character Relationships in Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban: Why Hermione in Ron's Arms After Buckbeak's Execution?
In the movie Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, a pivotal moment occurs after the execution of Buckbeak. Hermione is seen in Ron's arms, a scene that has sparked much discussion among fans. Some interpret this as Ron and Hermione's romantic connection, while others argue it highlights their deep bond as friends. This essay seeks to explore the emotional context of this scene, the intentions of the screenwriter, and the reasons behind this specific cinematic choice.
Character Relationships
At this point in the story, Ron and Hermione's friendship is highlighted, and their bond is portrayed as particularly strong. Ron's comforting gesture shows his concern for Hermione and reinforces their connection. This moment is heavy with emotion due to the tragic fate of Buckbeak and the emotional weight on the trio. It is a moment where the dynamics of their relationship are explored, showcasing how they support each other in difficult times.
Emotional Context
The scene is an emotional one, characterized by sorrow and compassion. Ron's action of wrapping his arms around Hermione serves not only to comfort her but also to remind the audience of the trio's emotional support system. It is a tender moment that deepens the audience's understanding of their relationships and the emotional impact of the events they face.
Screenwriter Decisions
While the screenwriter may have preferences regarding character pairings, decisions in scenes often prioritize narrative coherence and character arcs over romantic implications. The choice to have Hermione in Ron's arms is more about illustrating their friendship and the emotional weight of the situation than about romantic shipping. The screenplay is rooted in portraying the characters' emotional journeys truthfully and authentically.
Context of the Novel
Goblet of Fire was released before Prisoner of Azkaban, and it was in this novel that Ron and Hermione's budding romantic relationship is established. Even if the director read the novel or if J.K. Rowling had some input and told him a Hermione/Harry thing wasn't happening, the choice to show Hermione in Ron's arms still had to align with the narrative needs of the film.
Critical Analysis
Some argue that the scene looks a bit contrived, with more genuine feeling in the pop on the chin that Emma Watson gave Tom Felton in their scene together. It is true that the screenwriter was hired to write the screenplay based on the books. While fans can debate the merits of his work, he was not tasked with rewriting the story so much that it would be unrecognizable. Therefore, he had to work within the framework of the story and the characters as they were defined in the novels.
To summarize, the scene of Hermione in Ron's arms after Buckbeak's execution is a deliberate choice by the screenwriter to emphasize the strength of their friendship and the emotional impact of the event. The choice is rooted in narrative coherence and authenticity, rather than romantic implications. This is a testament to the professionalism of the screenwriter and his commitment to staying true to the source material while enhancing the audience's understanding of the characters and their relationships.