Introduction

The dynamics of the wizarding world in the Harry Potter series are a complex web of prophecy, fate, and desire for power. One intriguing hypothetical is what might have transpired if Lord Voldemort had chosen Neville Longbottom instead of Harry Potter as the subject of the prophecy. This article explores the potential implications of such a twist in the story.

Understanding the Original Prophecy

The prophecy that set Harry Potter on the path to battle Lord Voldemort was made in late 1979 or early 1980, before the births of both Harry and Neville. The prophecy, as stated in the movie and book, dictates that 'the one with the power to vanquish the Dark Lord approaches ... born as the seventh month dies, and the Dark Lord will mark him as his equal, but he will have power that the Dark Lord knows not. Yet to defeat the Dark Lord will the boy with the power vanquish him and be vanquished; the one born as the seventh month dies, shall bring forth the power the Dark Lord knows not.'

Professor Snape’s Involvement and Interpretation

The part of the prophecy that Sage Voldemort is aware of is a more ominous warning: 'The one with the power to vanquish the Dark Lord approaches ... born as the seventh month dies, and the Dark Lord shall mark him as his equal.'

Professor Severus Snape, who eavesdropped on the prophecy, relayed a truncated version to Voldemort, focusing on the aspect that Voldemort already had knowledge of: the approaching birth. Snape, known for his willingness to serve the Dark Lord, did not reveal the full prophecy, especially the part about Neville.

What If Voldemort Chose Neville Longbottom?

Let us consider the possibility that Lord Voldemort chose Neville Longbottom as the subject of the prophecy. Several theoretical scenarios emerge:

Time and Decision-Making

Voldemort would have had far more time to make a decision, as the prophecy was made before the birth of both Harry and Neville. Voldemort, who is over 50 years old, would have had plenty of people who had defied him multiple times. The prophecy could easily refer to any number of individuals rather than just babies.

Additionally, the phrase 'born as the seventh month dies' can have multiple interpretations. It could refer to the approaching birth, a future birth, a past birth, or even to someone who has already lived and will live again. The mention of 'those' could imply a group or a species, not just a couple.

Interpreting the Key Clause: 'Born to Those Who Have Touched Him Other Times'

The phrase 'born to those who have touched him other times' is open to interpretation. It could refer to a group of people who have defied Voldemort multiple times, such as the French, the goblins, or even the Gryffindor house. If Voldemort chose someone from the Gryffindor house, it would significantly alter the power dynamics of the story.

The Impact on the Wizarding World

Choosing Neville Longbottom instead of Harry would have profound consequences for the wizarding world:

Altered Dynamics in the Battle Against Voldemort

Instead of Harry, Neville would have been the primary focus of the Order of the Phoenix and the prophecy. This would have meant a different approach to the battle against Voldemort, where the focus would be on supporting Neville and preparing him for his eventual confrontation with the Dark Lord.

Changing Personalities and Relationships

If Neville had been targeted, his relationships with Dumbledore, Snape, and Harry would have been drastically different. Dumbledore, who would have been aware of the prophecy, may have chosen a different approach in mentoring Neville. Snape, having his true intentions revealed, might have played a more prominent role in Neville's life, possibly as a mentor and protector.

The Role of Hogwarts

The school of magic, Hogwarts, would also have faced significant changes. Instead of a focus on Harry and the Trio, the school's curriculum and magical community would have emphasized Neville's growth and potential as the future champion.

Conclusion

The choice of Neville Longbottom, instead of Harry, as the subject of the prophecy would have dramatically altered the course of the story. It would have affected the dynamics of the battle against Voldemort, the relationships among key characters, and the direction of Hogwarts. The wizarding world, as we know it in the Harry Potter series, would have been vastly different, leading to a unique journey of discovery and conflict.