If Hermione Granger Were Sorted Into Slytherin: How it Would Change Everything

Imagine a universe in which the beloved witch Hermione Granger, often a symbol of courage and bravery, was sorted into the House of Slytherin. This hypothetical scenario sparks a cascade of knock-on effects, particularly for the wizarding trio, with Harry Potter and Ron Weasley. Let's explore how this would change their world dramatically.

Albus Dumbledore and the Sorting Hat

While Professor Dumbledore's belief in a student's choices and character could sway the Sorting Hat to place Harry in Gryffindor, if the Hat had insisted on Slytherin, Harry's fate could have been dramatically different. The Hat had apparently intended for Harry to be sorted into Slytherin, and if he had wavered in his certainty, the Hat might have persisted, leading to a very different Hogwarts journey for all three.

Hermione's Close Relationship with Harry

A scenario where Hermione was placed into Slytherin would have a profound impact on Harry. Instead of being in Gryffindor, Harry and Hermione would likely form an unbreakable bond from early on. The shared experience of being non-purebloods in a predominantly pure-blood house would create a strong sense of camaraderie. Harry would recognize early on that not all Slytherins were dark, mirroring Hermione's own views.

Additionally, they would likely befriend another non-pureblood in their year, Tracey Davis, who, while less explored in the books, is known to be intelligent and gifted in her magic. The new trio, consisting of Hermione, Harry, and Tracey, could forge an even tighter and more effective friendship, as they would have a shared struggle and support system at Hogwarts.

Challenges and Adversity

Despite the potential for a strong and positive relationship, several challenges still lay in store. If Hermione survived the first night, she might try to integrate herself into the House of Slytherin, potentially through sheer force of personality. However, her antics might make her unpopular, and she might face prejudice and snobbery.

Regardless of her efforts to win over the Slytherins, she would eventually either learn about the impending return of Voldemort, likely not warming to the dark wizard, or would be forced to flee the school due to her muggle-born status.

The Fall of Hogwarts and the Return of Voldemort

The stakes would be even higher if Hermione did not return to Gryffindor. With Harry not receiving the same guidance and information about Nicholas Flamel, Quirrell would have a much easier path to the Philosopher's Stone. Dumbledore's best efforts would not be enough to prevent Voldemort from discovering the stone and retrieving it, leading to a catastrophic return of Lord Voldemort and the descent into darkness.

Conclusion

The hypothetical scenario of Hermione Granger being sorted into Slytherin reveals a complex and possibly darker path for the wizarding world. It highlights the importance of character, friendship, and the choices that students face at Hogwarts. While the idea of Hermione in Slytherin might seem intriguing, it ultimately underscores the significance of her bravery, loyalty, and courage in the Potterverse.