How to Identify a Fake Goth or Emo: A Guide for the Sensitive Observer

Whether you're at a local bar, a music concert, or even just around your neighborhood, it can be challenging to tell the difference between a true goth or emo and a tourist or someone in cosplay. This guide will help you navigate these situations and understand the key differences that set authentic from the inauthentic.

Understanding the Subculture

First and foremost, it is essential to understand what being a goth or emo traditionally means. Goths and emos are two distinct subcultures, but they share some overlapping themes and aesthetics. Goths tend to value introspection and melancholy, while emos are more focused on emotional expression through visuals and music. Both subcultures reject mainstream culture and often identify with themes of darkness, rebellion, and individuality.

Distinguishing Authenticity

So, how do you know if someone is a real goth or emo or just a tourist trying to look the part? Here are several telltale signs to look out for:

Tourists in Costume

There are clear indicators that someone is a tourist or wearing a costume. Some of the most common telltale signs include:

Wearing specific brands without understanding the subculture: Many tourists will buy replicas of iconic clothing items, such as Doc Martens and black raincoats, without understanding the deeper cultural significance behind the choices. These items are often worn to fit a certain aesthetic but not necessarily part of the authentic experience.

Dark Makeup: While dark makeup is a common feature of goths and emos, it is often applied in a novelty, attention-seeking way by those in costume. Authentic individuals will typically apply makeup to enhance their natural features or to complement their personal style, not as a primary statement.

Dress Code: Tourists often stick to black clothing, but authentic goths and emos will vary in their attire. They may wear gothic-inspired brands such as Carhartt, Nudie Jeans, STONE ISLE, or self-designed outfits that express their personal identity and artistic vision.

Understanding the Language and Subculture

One of the most crucial aspects of identifying a fake goth or emo is understanding their communication and behavior. Authentic individuals engage in the subculture more deeply, participating in discussions, wearing appropriate clothing, and displaying a genuine interest in the music, literature, and aesthetics that define the community.

Musical Taste: Goths and emos have specific musical tastes, often including bands like Bauhaus, The Smiths, and My Bloody Valentine. Authentic individuals will be familiar with these artists and actively seeking out new bands within the subculture. Tourists may just wear black and have heard of these bands but aren’t actively engaged with the scene.

Literature and Art: Both goths and emos appreciate dark, brooding literature and art, such as the works of Edgar Allan Poe, E.A. Poe, and Tim Burton films. Authentic members of these subcultures will have read or watched these and similar artists and will be part of online communities that discuss these works.

Online Presence: Many authentic goths and emos have a presence on social media, often engaged in discussions about the subculture. Tourists may create infrequent or superficial accounts without a deep understanding or interest in the community.

Behavioral Cues

Behavior can also provide clues as to whether someone is a real goth or emo. Authentic individuals often display behaviors that resonate with the aesthetic and cultural values of the subculture. They might use specific slang terms, or express a general interest and respect for the community.

Body Language: Authentic goths and emos often exhibit a certain kind of emotional depth and restraint. They can be introspective and emotive, talking about feelings and personal struggles. Tourists may appear more outward and performative, using dramatic gestures and exaggerated expressions to compensate for their lack of genuine connection to the subculture.

Attitude: A true goth or emo will have a natural, inner attitude that reflects the aesthetics of the subculture. This includes a certain level of detachment and melancholy. Tourists may adopt poses or mimic attitudes without this authentic emotional connection.

Conclusion

Identifying a fake goth or emo is challenging, but with the right knowledge and an observant eye, you can often distinguish between authentic and costume-wearing individuals. It's important to approach the subculture with respect, recognizing that for many, it is more than a fashion choice but a deeply personal expression of identity and culture.

Remember, the best way to engage with any subculture is to seek a genuine understanding and connection. By being informed, respectful, and open to learning, we can foster a more inclusive and diverse community for everyone.