Harry vs. Voldemort: Which Character Was More Real and Justified?
In the vast realm of the Harry Potter series, J.K. Rowling masterfully created two characters that stand as polar opposites: Harry Potter and Lord Voldemort. While both characters are justified in their roles, they represent different aspects of human nature and society. This essay will explore their justification and how they fit within the narrative, ultimately concluding that while both characters are portrayed to some degree, Harry aligns more closely with real-world scenarios.
Voldemort: A Character Depicted Through Choices
Lord Voldemort, whose birth name is Tom Marvolo Riddle, begins his journey as an orphan with a tragic past due to the effects of a love potion. This lack of love sets the foundation for his character. Unbeknownst to him or those around him, Voldemort was a prodigious sorcerer who used his powers to his own advantage, possibly as a form of defense mechanism against a harsh and unforgiving world. His early life in the orphanage is marked by his mastery over magic and his cruel use of it, suggesting a deep-seated resentment towards those who he perceives as weak or different.
Through his storyline, Voldemort is portrayed as a symbol of the destructive power of unchecked ambition and the relentless pursuit of power. His desire to eliminate muggleborn wizards and understand his ultimate goal of supremacy over Muggles is seen as a method to achieve his goal of power. However, it is his inability to empathize with others and his disregard for their feelings that ultimately leads to his downfall. His lack of consideration for others' feelings and potentials is what ultimately destroys him, a tragic but clear consequence of his actions.
Key Points: Early life marked by the effects of a love potion Orphaned, yet a prodigious wizard Immense bitterness and desire for power Unable to consider others' feelings, leading to his downfall
Harry Potter: A Character of Love and Forgiveness
Harry Potter, in contrast, is a beacon of love and compassion. Unlike Voldemort, Harry's journey is marked by a series of challenges including neglect and abuse, yet he remains a symbol of goodness in the world of magical characters. While he hated his relatives the Dursleys, he never sought to harm them deliberately. In fact, he struggled to believe that he was a wizard at all.
Harry's transformation from a neglected child to a powerful wizard is attributed to his strong sense of love and empathy. He prioritizes friendship and bravery and understands that power is not everything. Perhaps the most poignant example of Harry's justification is his ultimate sacrifice to protect others, even though it led to the creation of a part of Voldemort's soul within him. This act of love and compassion demonstrates his core value system and his willingness to put others before himself.
Key Points: Fostered by love and a sense of caring Sacrificed himself to protect others Understood that power is not everything Valued friendship and bravery
The Realism of Both Characters
While both characters are pivotal to the narrative, their levels of realism differ. Voldemort is more aligned with real-world scenarios where unchecked ambition and power lead to downfall. His character arc allows the reader to understand the consequences of his choices, providing a clear and logical narrative progression.
Harry, while also a complex character, represents a more idealistic view of the world. His character arc, although rooted in fantasy, still mirrors real-world themes of love, forgiveness, and the importance of moral values. The challenges he faces, including the neglect and abuse, provide a realistic backdrop to his transformation.
JK Rowling herself hinted at the unrealistic nature of Harry's childhood when Dumbledore compliments Harry in Book 5 for confining him in his office against his will, revealing the larger context of a privileged environment.
Key Points: Voldemort's character is more realistic, showcasing the consequences of unchecked ambition Harry's character is more idealistic, valuing love, friendship, and forgiveness JK Rowling acknowledged the unrealistic elements in Harry's backstory
Conclusion
In conclusion, both Harry Potter and Voldemort are justified within the narrative of the Harry Potter series. However, while Voldemort represents the destructive potential of power and the importance of empathy, Harry symbolizes the power of love, friendship, and compassion. Both characters, despite their polar opposite nature, play a crucial role in the larger narrative, fighting for their own survival and the greater good of the wizarding world.
Key Takeaways: Harry embodies values of love and forgiveness Voldemort's realism lies in his descent into darkness due to unchecked ambition Both characters evoke real-world themes and provide valuable lessons