**Introduction**
The deep-rooted enmity between Harry Potter and Severus Snape is one of the most intriguing aspects of the Harry Potter series. Despite Snape saving Harry's life multiple times, Harry struggles to accept him as anything other than a villain. Why did Harry have such strong hatred towards Snape when Snape, seemingly, held a grudge against Harry as well?
In this article, we delve into the complex dynamics of Harry and Snape's relationship. We explore the reasons behind Snape's harsh treatment of Harry and how Harry's experiences contributed to his perception of Snape as a figure of pure malice. We contend that Snape was not simply a 'bad guy' but a character whose actions and mannerisms contributed significantly to fostering Harry's resentment.
Verbal and Psychological Abuse
Snape's first encounter with Harry sets the tone for their tumultuous relationship. In Harry's first potions class, Snape publicly humiliated Harry by mocking his dead father. This event is one of several instances where Snape verbally abused Harry:
Classroom Mockery: Snape frequently mocked Harry's parents and, by extension, Harry himself. For example, in the first potions lesson, Snape scolded Harry for Neville's mistake, making fun of his fame even before Harry had a chance to speak.
Verbal Torture: Snape mercilessly mocked Harry's father, James, during their lessons. This was an especially painful experience for an orphaned boy like Harry.
Targets of Bullying: Snape subjected Neville to both verbal and psychological abuse, exploiting his vulnerability as a target for bullying. Neville, an otherwise clumsy and unpopular student, became a frequent recipient of Snape's cruel words.
Threats and Exploitation
Beyond the classroom, Snape also employed more sinister methods to control and manipulate Harry:
Veritaserum: In the books and at least in certain adaptations, Snape is shown to have used Veritaserum to force Harry into revealing information, further violating his trust.
Dementor's Kiss: In third year, Snape attempted to have Harry's godfather, Sirius Black, subjected to the dementor's kiss. This act was deeply troubling to Harry, who was unaware of the true motives behind such a dangerous punishment.
OCCULUMENCY: When Snape tried to teach Harry occlumency, he was often cruel and unyielding, adding to Harry's impression of Snape's character as purely antagonistic.
Snape's Role in Harry's Life
Harry's relationship with Snape was further complicated by his role in Harry's early life:
Tragic Prophesy: Harry discovered that Snape, through no fault of his own, was indeed responsible for passing the prophecy that led to his parents' death and his later hardships with the Dursleys. This knowledge did not make it easier for Harry to accept Snape's redeeming qualities.
Voldemort's Creation: Snape, along with the other Death Eaters, was complicit in creating Voldemort, who was responsible for Harry's suffering. Protecting Harry was the least Snape could do after his actions.
The Question of Morality and Character
Snape, while portrayed as a complex and nuanced character, is often viewed as a 'bad guy' in the eyes of Harry:
Malfoy's Defense: Snape's desire to protect Lucius Malfoy and thereby protect his own position in the Death Eaters' organization was a significant factor in his actions. This shows a willingness to align with dark figures rather than standing alone for what is right.
More Than the Sworn Protectors: Despite swearing to protect Lily Potter, Snape was one of the three who caused her death. His later actions to protect Harry were the minimum expectation after his past wrongdoings.
Thus, while Snape plays a nuanced and pivotal role in the Harry Potter series, his methods and actions often contribute to Harry's enduring distrust.
In summary, the hatred between Harry and Snape is a result of Snape's persistent maltreatment, both verbal and psychological, as well as his involvement in significant events in Harry's life. Snape's actions, while partially motivated by moral and personal obligations, ultimately contributed to a complex and often adversarial relationship between the two characters.