Giuliani's Perception of Borat’s Daughter in 'Borat'

The movie 'Borat' featuring the character of Borat-manager, portrayed by Sacha Baron Cohen, has sparked numerous discussions regarding the perception of his character's daughter. A common misconception or misinterpretation is that Giuliani, a key character in the film, believed Borat's daughter to be 15 years old. However, this belief is both incorrect and rooted in a misunderstanding of the film's construction and the age of the actress involved.

The Filmed Scene

When examining the specific scene involving Giuliani and Borat's daughter, it becomes clear that Giuliani's suggestion that the character is 15 is not based on a personal belief but rather a character description. In the film, as seen from Giuliani's perspective, the scene is positioned in a way that suggests Borat's daughter's age. However, the first mention of her being 15 does not come until the end of the scene, when Borat enters the room. It is important to note that this portrayal is entirely within the context of the film and is part of the narrative construction.

The Reality of the Actress's Age

Contrary to the misconception, Borat's daughter does not actually appear to be 15 during her interview with Giuliani. The character's age and the actress's portrayal of her are significant points of interest. Understanding the age of the actress involved is crucial in dispelling this myth. In reality, the actress who played this role is substantially older than 15, which adds another layer of complexity to the film's representation and public perception.

Giuliani’s Perspective and the Actor's Role

When we consider Giuliani's character, it's important to note that his views and perceptions are shaped by the on-screen interactions he has. These interactions often serve as windows into his own prejudices and biases, rather than providing a direct insight into an external reality. Thus, Giuliani's belief that Borat’s daughter is 15 is part of the broader narrative that the character is portraying.

Clarification and Context: It's essential to clarify that the character's perception of the daughter's age is not based on any factual information but rather the script and the context within the film. The character’s perception reflects the story he is part of, rather than an actual understanding or belief in the world outside the frame of the film. This interpretation is a reflection of the character's prejudices and not a reflection of reality.

Conclusion

It is a misconception to assume that Giuliani believed Borat's daughter was 15 years old during their interaction in the film. Giuliani’s perspective is constructed within the film's narrative; the first mention of the daughter's age comes from within the context of the scene, specifically after Borat enters the room. The actress who played the role of Borat's daughter is significantly older than 15, which naturally affects her performance and the audience's perception. Therefore, Giuliani’s belief in the daughter's age can be seen as a product of the film's construction rather than a factual assertion.

Additional Context: For a deeper understanding of such misconceptions in film, it is vital to distinguish between the on-screen representation and the factual reality. Understanding the roles and performances of actors in their respective scenes can help avoid such misinterpretations. This clarification is important for maintaining a realistic and nuanced understanding of the film and its characters.