Gandalf’s Choice: Bilbo or Thorin for the Quest?
In the stories of The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings, characters like Gandalf, Bilbo Baggins, and Thorin Oakenshield appear. Questions often arise about why certain choices were made. One common query is whether Gandalf chose Bilbo Baggins over Thorin Oakenshield for the adventure. Let's delve into the reasons behind this choice and explore the context of their role in the story.
Was Gandalf's Choice Based on Courage and Values?
Often, it is suggested that Gandalf, known for his wisdom and valor, chose Bilbo over Thorin because of his courage and the values he represented. While Bilbo is brave and resourceful, these qualities alone were not the primary reason for his selection.
It is important to consider that Gandalf was not solely interested in bravery or specific personal characteristics. Instead, he was looking for a specific set of qualities in an individual that could help achieve the quest's goals effectively.
Why Did Gandalf Choose Bilbo Baggins?
Gandalf chose Bilbo for a specific reason. He needed someone who was both brave and resourceful but also small enough to fit into the secret entrances leading to Smaug's lair. Bilbo, a hobbit, fit this requirement perfectly while the dwarves, being larger, would have been unable to pass through the entrance undetected.
Context in the Story
The Lonely Mountain, also known as Erebor, was the location of Smaug's lair. Thorin Oakenshield was part of the original 13 members recruited by Gandalf. However, it is worth noting that the 13 represented only a portion of the Dwarven kin who had fled from the dragon's wrath. Bilbo was hired as a burglar, a role that required stealth and cunning, qualities that hobbits were known for.
Additionally, hobbits did not wear iron-shod boots or carry heavy armor, which would have attracted unwanted attention. These details are important in understanding why Gandalf chose Bilbo and why the adventure would be more feasible with his presence.
Did Gandalf Choose Bilbo Over Thorin?
From the story's perspective, Gandalf chose Bilbo not by making Thorin's presence less important, but by ensuring the quest's success. While Thorin was a key leader and the heir to the lost kingdom, he needed an expert like Bilbo to succeed in their mission.
For Gandalf, the goal was to align the dwarves and secure a stronghold against the dragon. The choice of Bilbo was strategic, ensuring that the dwarves had the best chance of achieving their objectives.
Beyond Bilbo and Thorin
Ultimately, Bilbo's role in securing the ring and later Gandalf's realization that their mission was about disposing of the enemy covertly, led to the emergence of Frodo and Sam in the larger narrative of The Lord of the Rings.
By choosing Bilbo, Gandalf ensured that the quest for Erebor would have a better chance of success, showcasing the importance of strategic thinking and the right fit for the task at hand.
For more in-depth analysis and discussion of The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings, readers may refer to the extensive literature, film analyses, and academic writings on these subjects.