GI-dle vs Black Pink: An In-Depth Analysis of the Controversy

Comparing musical groups like GI-dle and BLACKPINK can be subjective as different people have different preferences and musical tastes. Both groups have achieved significant success and have their own unique styles and strengths.

Popularity and Music

GI-dle, a South Korean girl group known for their versatility and distinct musical style, has become a prominent figure in the K-pop industry. They have released songs that incorporate elements of K-pop, hip-hop, EDM, and more. Their music often features a mix of genres, and they are recognized for their creative input in their songs and performances.

BLACKPINK, another successful South Korean girl group, is known for their high-energy music, strong visuals, and global popularity. They are particularly known for their catchy pop and hip-hop-influenced tracks and their powerful stage presence.

Vocals and Rapping

When comparing vocals and rapping:

Vocals:

Rosès from BLACKPINK has a very sweet and melodic voice. Jisoo's voice is husky and deeper than other members. Jennie's voice is described as average. Lisa's voice is not bad but is not considered the best.

GI-dle:

Minny's voice is excellent. Miyeon's voice is heavenly. Soojin's vocals are considered good. Yuki's deep voice is very pretty. Shuhua's voice is described as average. Soyeon's voice is not described, but it is not considered very good.

Rapping:

Lisa and Jennie are considered to be very good rappers. Soyeon is the best rapper in K-pop, with the ability to rap very fast and write her own songs. Other members of both groups can also rap very well.

Dance and Visuals

Dance skills and visual aesthetics are significant factors in the success of K-pop groups:

Dance:

Lisa's dance is described as excellent. Soojin's dance is considered average. Yuki's dance is also described as average.

Visuals:

While both groups' members are considered drop-dead gorgeous, according to K-pop fans, BLACKPINK better fits the KBS (Korean Broadcasting System) aesthetic more than GI-dle.

Stage Presence:

GI-dle is noted for having a better stage presence overall, particularly in terms of their combined vocal and rapping abilities. However, BLACKPINK is celebrated for their high-energy dance performances. In terms of the final tally:

GI-dle: 3

BLACKPINK: 2

It is important to recognize that while we can compare specific aspects of the groups, every artist is unique and should be respected for their contributions to the music industry. Both groups have their own strengths and fans who support them for various reasons.

Ultimately, the choice between GI-dle and BLACKPINK comes down to individual preferences. Both groups bring something special to the K-pop scene, and it's commendable that they continue to thrive and engage their dedicated fan bases.