Finger Picking vs Pick: The Debate on Electric Guitar Playing Techniques

When it comes to playing the electric guitar, whether you should finger pick or use a pick is a topic that has been debated among musicians for decades. In this article, we explore the benefits and reasons behind both methods, providing insights from renowned guitarists and experts in the field.

Why Some Prefer Finger Picking

For the past 40 years, many guitarists have opted to use their fingers for playing the electric guitar. The versatility of using four fingers is unmatched, particularly for intricate finger style playing. As a former finger stylist myself, I can confidently say that my four fingers are far more versatile than a pick.

Notable Finger Picking Artists

Derek Trucks: Watch a video of Derek Trucks from the Tedeschi Trucks band. His bare fingers on the strings demonstrate the preferred method of some electric guitar players. Matteo Mancuso: An extremely skilled and versatile guitar player from Italy. At a young age, he was already a prodigy and has since become a virtuoso. Watch his performance to see the power of finger picking on both electric and acoustic guitars.

Even when using a pick, it is held between your fingers and thumb, which are part of your hand. If you are referring to pure finger style with no pick, then it is certainly possible. Many musicians, including myself, have played for long periods without using a pick.

Benefits of Finger Picking

Stronger attack of the sound, a much softer and brighter tone, more precision for playing faster scale runs or riffs, and an increase in speed are a few of the reasons why professional guitarists such as Brian May, Mike Oldfield, and Mark Knopfler from Dire Straits prefer finger picking. These musicians have been known to use this technique for a seamless blend of classic and electric playing styles.

Flexibility and Sound

Finger picking also allows for a greater variety of sounds. The sound of a pick can be quite different and sometimes unappealing, especially when compared to the natural sound produced by fingers. For instance, when learning to play the guitar, I initially used the back of a matchbook cover as a pick before reverting to using my fingers to avoid the clicking noise of the pick on the string.

Why Some Resort to Using Picks

While finger picking offers many advantages, guitar picks still have their own merits. The sound produced by a pick can be unique and powerful, complementing certain playing styles and techniques. Some guitarists even use a hybrid technique, combining both finger picking and pick playing to enhance their sound.

Tone and Technique

Consider the tone and technique being used. Many players, including those who play with their thumbs, might find the tone unsatisfactory. On the other hand, skilled finger pickers can create breathtaking solos, as demonstrated by many blues players. The choice ultimately comes down to personal comfort and the desired sound. It's all about finding what works best for you!

Conclusion

Electric guitar playing techniques, whether finger picking or using a pick, can be tailored to individual preferences and playing styles. Both methods offer distinct advantages and can coexist in a guitarist's repertoire. Whether you're a beginner or a seasoned pro, understanding the benefits of both methods will help you decide which approach suits you best.