Exploring the Nuances Between 'This Makes Sense' and 'This is Making Sense'

Introduction: In the realm of communication, the English language often presents subtle differences between similar phrases. Two such phrases, 'This makes sense' and 'This is making sense', are frequently used but carry slightly different connotations. Understanding these nuances can enhance one's ability to communicate effectively.

Basic Differences

'This makes sense' is a straightforward statement, often used when one has fully comprehended or agrees with the idea, explanation, or story presented to them. It communicates a clear and direct alignment between the speaker's understanding and the content at hand.

'This is making sense' on the other hand, suggests a dynamic process of understanding. It implies that the speaker is either in the middle of receiving an explanation or telling a story, and the information is becoming clear to them at that precise moment. This phrase adds an element of progression to the communication process.

Idiomatic Use

This Makes Sense: This construction is idiomatic and is used to express agreement or understanding after a complete explanation or story has been provided. For example, if someone explains a complex idea or procedure in detail, you might say 'This makes sense' as a way of acknowledging that you understand it.

This is Making Sense: This phrase is also idiomatic, but it carries a different tone. It suggests an ongoing process of comprehension. For instance, if someone is explaining something step-by-step, and as they do, the information is becoming clearer to you, you might say 'This is making sense.'

Grammatical Nuances

The choice between 'makes' and 'is making' hinges on the time and nature of the event. 'Makes' in 'This makes sense' refers to a permanent or habitual sense of understanding. It is a static condition, suggesting that what has been presented is logically or factually sound.

In contrast, 'is making sense' in 'This is making sense' introduces an element of action and ongoing comprehension. The 'is making' form indicates a progressive or evolving process. It is more suited to situations where information is being presented in real-time and the speaker is actively processing it.

The use of the demonstrative pronoun 'this' is also notable. 'This' is often used with 'makes sense' because it points to something specific and nearby, making the statement more immediate and relevant. When used with 'is making sense', it can be less common, as it may be seen as slightly less precise or engaging in casual conversation.

Usage Examples

Example 1: 'I just heard about the new policy the company is implementing. This makes sense. It aligns with our goals and strategies.'

This example clearly indicates that after hearing the explanation, the speaker agrees with and understands the new policy.

Example 2: 'As you're explaining the new software, I'm following along. This is making sense. I can see how it will integrate with our current systems.'

This example shows the speaker understanding the explanation as it is being given step-by-step, indicating an active process of comprehension.

Conclusion

Understanding the subtle differences between 'This makes sense' and 'This is making sense' enhances one's ability to communicate effectively in various contexts. Knowing when to use each phrase ensures that your message is received in the way you intended. Whether it's the static sense of understanding or a dynamic process of comprehension, the choice of phrase can make a significant difference in how your message is received.

Related Keywords

idiomatic expressions: idiomatic expressions in English, common idiomatic phrases, idioms in daily conversation

sense: communication strategies, clear communication, effective communication techniques

communication: effective communication, interpersonal communication, improving communication skills