Why Do I Love Science Fiction and Yet Loathe Doctor Who?

Often, science fiction holds a special place in the hearts of many fans, evoking a sense of wonder, exploration, and endless possibilities. But for some, a cherished genre like science fiction can have a conflicting side. The Doctor Who phenomenon might be a prime example of this dichotomy.

In contrast to pure, well-crafted science fiction, where imagination and creativity are paramount, Doctor Who has had its share of clunkers over its near-six-decade history. Despite the occasional triumphs, its broader appeal can often falter due to subpar writing, direction, and acting. However, there is something inherently engrossing about this show, making it irresistible to fans who find themselves intrinsically drawn to it, no matter the quality.

Entertainment Through Tribulations

Doctor Who, like any long-running series, has its peaks and troughs. Yet, amid this miasma of bad writing and production, there lies a veritable treasure trove of memorable moments and beloved characters. Episodes such as Heaven Sent, The Husbands of River Song, and the Season 21 episode "The Doctor Falls" have become iconic for their sheer brilliance, despite the show's overall trajectory. These episodes serve as a testament to the enduring charm of the series, even when it doesn't quite deserve it.

My Personal Journey with Doctor Who

My own introduction to Doctor Who mirrored the skepticism many have. I initially came across the clip about the Doctor and Van Gogh in the museum, which, to my surprise, was highly entertaining. This prompted me to watch the show, and I began with the first episode starring Christopher Eccleston as the Ninth Doctor. Unfortunately, my first impression was less than stellar; the visuals, the monster, and the narrative all fell short of expectations, leaving me disillusioned.

However, the show's resilience and my curiosity pulled me back in. A second chance came when I found out that a favorite actor, David Tennant, portrayed the Eleventh Doctor. Starting from the second season of David Tennant's tenure, I gradually found the series improving. The intense character development and the dynamic companions captivated me, making me question my initial judgment.

Recommended Start Points

If you're still skeptical, I suggest you start with either the Second Season of the 10th Doctor or the Fourth Season of the 11th Doctor. Personally, I highly recommend the 11th season, even though 10th is often favored. The 11th Doctor's depth and the production quality, all thanks to David Tennant and Matt Smith, offer a fantastic gateway to the Doctor Who universe.

In conclusion, while Doctor Who may not always be a perfect match, the mix of mesmerizing storytelling, iconic characters, and dedicated fan culture makes it a series both to love and occasionally begrudge. As someone who has navigated this duality, I hope my experience can help others find their way through the Time Vortex.