Exploring the Discontinuity in the DCEU: The Joker, Jared Leto, and Joaquin Phoenix
The DC Extended Universe (DCEU) has seen a series of changes and discontinuities, especially concerning the portrayal of the Joker, with various actors stepping in to bring their unique interpretations to the iconic villain. This article delves into the reasons behind these changes, including the impact of personal performances, the standalone nature of unrelated films, and new directions within the DCEU.
Why Did the DCEU Consider Replacing Jared Leto?
The decision to replace Jared Leto as the Joker in the DC Universe came primarily from audience and critical reception. Leto's portrayal was not universally well-received, leading filmmakers to seek a fresh, different take on the character. Additionally, the standalone nature of the Joker film, which took place in 1970, meant it did not conform to the narrative and tone established by the DCEU. The Suicide Squad's setting in 1970 with its distinct version of Harley Quinn further distanced this film from the continuity of the larger universe.
Why Is Joaquin Phoenix Not Taking Over?
Although many fans wish for Joaquin Phoenix to star as the Joker, the continuity and creative integrity of films set in different eras make such a transition highly unlikely. Phoenix's Joker in the standalone movie is decidedly different from the DCEU timeline. His character is set in the 1980s, while the DCEU is currently centered in the 2010s. Given Phoenix's age, he would be 76 by the time events of Man of Steel (2013) occur, which would be anachronistic.
Current State of the DCEU
The DCEU has shifted its focus towards more light-hearted, standalone films like Aquaman, Wonder Woman, and the standalone Joker film. The latter, under the DC Black Label, stands as a complete departure from the broader DCEU narrative. Jared Leto remains interested in the role, but the plans have not yet been confirmed. Additionally, Christian Bale will not reprise his role as Batman, as Warner Bros. and Matt Reeves wanted a younger, more contemporary take on the character. This shift means that the Batman franchise will not be part of the DCEU in its original planned sequence.
Future of the DCEU
The DCEU is expected to continue with sequels involving familiar solo characters like Aquaman, Shazam, and possibly Black Adam. Future films may also include the Lantern Corps and the Flash. However, the order and timing of these films will differ from the original plans. Jared Leto is set to return to the role of the Joker in Suicide Squad 2, which will be released after the Phoenix Joker film, but some continuity and contractual issues may arise if Phoenix's Joker were to overlap with previous films.
Conclusion
The evolution of the DCEU means audiences can expect a mix of standalone films and interconnected narratives. While some changes and discontinuities may seem jarring, they often serve to refresh the DCEU and bring new, captivating stories to the screen. Whether fans embrace these shifts remains to be seen, but one thing is certain: the iconic figure of the Joker will continue to captivate audiences in various unique ways.