Exploring the Disadvantages of Using Heavy Guitar Picks
As a seasoned guitarist, my journey with different guitar picks has shown me that there are both advantages and disadvantages to using heavy picks. In this article, I explore the downsides of using heavier guitar picks and share my personal experiences with different pick types.
Understanding the Sound Differences
One of the first considerations when choosing a pick thickness is the sound it produces. Many guitarists prefer medium or light picks for their clarity and articulation, whereas heavier picks can offer a richer, fuller tone. I experimented with a medium pick and progressively moved to a heavier one, finding that my preference lies somewhere in the middle.
Articulation vs. Sound Quality
Using a heavier pick like a 1.5mm can sometimes lack the definition and articulation that comes with thinner picks, such as a 1.2mm. The sound might become darker and less precise, which could be a disadvantage for detailed playing or certain genres where clarity is essential. However, different materials can affect the sound, and some heavy picks, like the Planet Waves D’Addario black 1.5mm, can provide a dark but controlled sound that is suitable for legato playing and almost eliminates the pick attack.
Material and Feel
Different materials can change the feel and sound dramatically. For instance, the Dunlop Gator Grips at 1.5mm feel almost like wax and are surprisingly bright compared to the Duralin 1.5mm from D’Addario. These low-noise picks provide a lighter sound, which some may find beneficial, but again, it very much depends on personal preference.
Learning and Adaptation
When we first start playing, thinner picks are easier and more forgiving, allowing us to learn proper technique without being too harsh on our fingertips. However, as we grow more skilled, we often transition to thicker picks to enhance control and string targeting. It is important to note that while some players might argue that thinner picks provide better control, this is a general statement and may not apply to everyone.
Sound Divergence Based on Material
The same thickness can produce varying sounds based on different materials and compositions. This is why choosing the right pick involves considering not only the thickness but also the material. For complex genres like slap bass on an acoustic guitar, a 1.0 to 1.2mm pick might be more appropriate, whereas a thinner pick would be ideal for plectrum-based playing.
Personal Preference and Comfort
Ultimately, the choice of pick thickness is a matter of personal comfort and preference. A fair amount of heaviness, along with a somewhat rounded tip, allows for more accurate and faster gliding over the strings. However, many players prefer lighter, thinner picks with sharp tips. There are no hard and fast rules; it's all about what suits your style and gives you the best tone for your playing.
Professional Perspectives
Some professional players prefer heavier picks and different shapes, but that is just their preference. I, however, find that genuine tortoiseshell picks were the best; although they are not available anymore due to conservation efforts. The comfort and quality of these picks can't be matched by modern alternatives.
To conclude, while heavy guitar picks can offer a rich, full-bodied sound, they may lack the articulation some players require, especially for intricate or controlled playing. The best choice depends on your individual preferences and the type of music you play. So, don’t be afraid to experiment with different pick thicknesses and materials to find what works best for you.