Examining the Factors Behind Rhaella’s Miscarriages and Daenerys’ Fertility: Genetics, Environment, and Magical Variables
Rhaella Targaryen, the mother of Daenerys Targaryen, endured multiple miscarriages, which have fascinated fans and scholars alike. Meanwhile, Daenerys was able to carry Rhaego to term with relative ease. This article will delve into the possible reasons behind these contrasting outcomes, examining factors such as genetic predispositions, environmental circumstances, and any potential magical influences at play.
Genetic Factors: The Targaryen Bloodline and Potential Issues
Both Rhaella and Daenerys come from the same lineage, known for its unique characteristics which can include fertility issues. However, the specific genetic factors affecting each individual might differ, leading to varying outcomes in their pregnancies. Rhaella experienced multiple miscarriages, potentially due to a combination of factors including potential recessive genetic traits that could result in non-viable fetuses or placentas even if one copy of the gene was present in Daenerys.
Environmental Factors: Differences in Circumstances
The environments in which Rhaella and Daenerys lived can also play a significant role in their reproductive health. Rhaella lived during a tumultuous time marked by political instability and personal trauma, which could have adversely affected her reproductive health. On the other hand, Daenerys experienced a more stable period after gaining confidence and agency, which may have positively influenced her overall health and fertility.
Health and Age: A Comparison
Daenerys was younger and in better health when she conceived Rhaego, compared to Rhaella during her pregnancies. This age and health difference might have contributed to the easier conception and successful pregnancy for Daenerys.
Magical Influences: The Role of Lore
In the A Song of Ice and Fire series, there are instances of magical influence, such as the use of the ‘Would You Lift the Stone’ doctrine by Mirri Mas Mharth, which could have additional layers of complexity to the childbirth and fertility narratives.
Comparative Analysis: Different Circumstances and Outcomes
It’s important to note that Rhaella’s inability to carry her fetuses to term wasn’t due to an inability to conceive but rather the struggle during the perinatal period. If Rhaella and Daenerys were carriers of a recessive gene or a combination of genes that could result in non-viable fetuses, Daenerys would be drawing from a different gene pool, which could mitigate the risk.
Rhaella’s experiences under an abusive and philandering husband may have worsened her high-risk pregnancies. In contrast, Daenerys, while facing her own share of challenges, lived in a more stable environment and was generally happier during her pregnancy.
Ethical and Philosophical Considerations: The ‘Hitler’ Dilemma
The reference to the ‘Would You Lift the Stone’ doctrine is often interpreted in a philosophical, physics, or ethical context. Fans have debated whether the act of eliminating a harmful fetus, such as Rhaego, could be considered a form of prevention of future harm. It’s important to recognize that in the narrative, Mirri Mas Mharth’s actions were both dangerous and unethical, leading to the tragic loss of Rhaego.
Concluding Thoughts
The contrasting experiences of Rhaella and Daenerys regarding pregnancy and miscarriage can be attributed to a combination of genetic predispositions, environmental circumstances, and the overall health and well-being of the mother during pregnancy. Understanding these factors provides insight into the complex and multifaceted nature of reproductive health in a fictional world, and highlights the importance of a stable and supportive environment for a healthy pregnancy.