Examining Miss World 2017s Controversial Answer: Mothers vs. Other Professions

Introduction

The Miss World 2017 event, particularly the question posed during the final round, Which profession deserves the highest salary and why, has sparked considerable debate. Two contestants, Miss Sri Lanka and Miss India, provided answers that received significant attention but were later found to be similar, leading to discussions about creativity, originality, and gender roles.

A Common Answer for a Universal Question?

The initial answer came from Miss Sri Lanka, Dusheni Silva, at the discussion round, where she responded, I think a mother who gives birth to a wonderful human being should be paid because 24x7 365... This response gained traction on social media and was subsequently echoed by Manushi Chhillar, Miss India, during the final round. Her response at 1:26:18 echoed Dusheni's answer, leading to questions about originality and the appropriateness of the response.

Analysis of the Critique

Several critics have pointed out the potential sexism in both responses, arguing that motherhood is not a profession but rather a role based on personal choice and duty. The comment that being a parent is a fortune, it is not a job or profession to be done because of your need highlights a common criticism that these answers lack genuine originality and depth.

Moreover, the assertion that loving is a nature, not a profession further emphasizes the circular reasoning in the responses. Some argue that while motherhood is undoubtedly invaluable and deserving of respect and recognition, it should not be conflated with a paid profession.

An Alternate Perspective

An alternative response that garnered support was the suggestion that soldiers should be the highest-paid profession. A soldier, while not a typical wage-earner, arguably protects the country's sovereignty and the lives of its citizens. In a stark contrast to the everyday jobs of sweeping or cleaning, a soldier's duties are often life-threatening and involve the ultimate sacrifice for the collective good.

The honor, respect, and possible financial rewards soldiers receive are often minimal compared to their contributions. Using this medium, we request the public to show our appreciation to these brave and selfless individuals who safeguard our nations.

Conclusion

The Miss World contest rewards not only beauty and grace but also the ability to articulate thoughtful and original responses. The answers provided by Miss Sri Lanka and Miss India, while touching on the importance of motherhood and other roles, were ultimately seen as less innovative and less fitting a top-tier response.

As discussions continue, the focus remains on fostering a culture of respect, equality, and originality. The debate about which profession deserves the highest salary and why serves as a reminder of the ongoing conversation about gender roles, societal values, and the recognition of hard work and selflessness in different professions.