Enola Holmes: A Modern Feminist Thriller or Historical Misfire?
Enola Holmes, the latest installment in the Sherlock Holmes franchise, has sparked controversy and praise. Some viewers and critics see it as a bold and empowering feminist narrative, while others argue that it is riddled with anachronisms and weaknesses. In this review, we delve into the film's strengths and weaknesses, the accuracy of its portrayal, and its place in the modern feminist landscape.
Feminist Signal or Historical Fiction?
Enola Holmes is often labeled as a feminist ‘Woke’ sermon, a modern story that signals to its audience about the contemporary values of equality and empowerment. The film features a strong female lead—Enola, played by Millie Bobby Brown—who does not shy away from confrontation and violence. However, the portrayal of Enola and her male counterparts has divided opinions. Critics argue that the film’s depiction of men as either helpless or oppressive caricatures is a step backward in true historical accuracy.
Millie Bobby Brown's Performance
Millie Bobby Brown's performance as Enola Holmes is worth highlighting. At 16 years old, she brings a sense of passion, charm, and eloquence to her role. Her ability to balance the emotional and physical demands of the character is commendable. Many reviewers have praised her for the effort and dedication she put into the film, making her the standout aspect of the movie.
Plot and Source Material
Enola Holmes is based on Nancy Springer's book series and does not follow the original Sherlock Holmes stories by Arthur Conan Doyle. Enola’s adventures are a significant departure from the canon, yet the film tries to incorporate themes of female empowerment within a Victorian setting. While some argue that this is a betrayal of the original source material, others see it as an opportunity to explore new perspectives and expand the narrative.
Historical Inaccuracy and Criticism
The film’s inaccuracy has been a major point of contention. Critics point out the anachronistic tropes, such as a 16-year-old girl engaging in fistfights with adult men and running away to London on her own. These elements are not plausible within the Victorian era context. The film’s portrayal of historical events, like the insertion of a black female Jujitsu instructor, are also seen as anachronistic and out of place.
Relevance to Modern Feminist Movements
Enola Holmes is often promoted as a feminist watch, offering young women a more empowered lead character. However, the film’s approach to female empowerment is questionable. Critics argue that the character needs to reject femininity and become more aggressive, which is a debatable step for true feminist representation. Instead, a truly empowering character should use her unique attributes and strengths to achieve her goals, rather than becoming more like men.
Conclusion: Entertaining and Inspiring, but with Weaknesses
Enola Holmes is a moderately entertaining film that is mostly harmless and suitable for a fun family adventure. It captures the attention of its target audience and offers themes of family, friendship, and romance. Fans of the original Sherlock Holmes stories might find it lacking, while those looking for inspiration and entertainment might find it enjoyable.
While the film has its flaws and inaccuracies, the performance of Millie Bobby Brown is commendable. If you are watching it with the expectation of a thrilling Victorian drama, you might be slightly disappointed. However, as a modern feminist narrative, it serves its purpose well, offering inspiration and empowerment to young women.
Rating: 7/10
Those interested in the film would do well to also explore the original Sherlock Holmes stories by Arthur Conan Doyle, which provide a rich and historically accurate context for the character of Enola Holmes.