Easiest Writing: Lyrics or Melody?

The age-old debate among songwriters about whether it's easier to create a complete song from scratch or to start with lyrics and then compose the melody has been going on for as long as the art of songwriting has existed. Neither approach is easy, but many songwriters find one method more convenient than the other.

Starting with Lyrics

For many, starting with lyrics is the most natural approach. The arrangement and diction of the lyrics often suggest a structure, rhythm, and melody contour. Essentially, this means that with lyrics as a starting point, the compositional process is already roughly one-third complete. The lyrics provide a ready-made framework, making it easier to build a melody and harmonize it with the flow of the words. This approach can be particularly appealing as it allows the inherent meaning and tone of the lyrics to guide the musical composition.

Starting with a Melody

Others, like legend Billy Joel, prefer to start with the melody. According to Joel himself, beginning with a melody gives greater freedom in composition and ensures that the rhythm is not compromised. He has found that starting with lyrics can sometimes stifle the melody, leading to a less organic musical creation. This method requires a songwriter to focus on the melody first and then integrate the lyrics seamlessly, ensuring that both elements complement each other harmoniously.

My Approach

Personally, I find it easier to compose a melody and then have a lyricist fit the lyrics to the tune rather than doing the matching myself or both tasks simultaneously. I have composed music for my own lyrics as well as for others, and both methods have their merits. While I have been writing songs all my life, I have yet to have my music recorded by a prominent artist. However, the joy and the art of creating resonate deeply with me, whether I start with lyrics or a melody.

The Inspiration Factor

The nature of inspiration plays a significant role in determining which route to take. For me, creating a melody is not always a strength. It can be challenging to combine melody and lyrics effectively, and sometimes it takes significant effort to find the perfect match. However, the end result is always rewarding, and the process, whether straightforward or convoluted, is part of the artistic journey.

Conclusion and Advice

In conclusion, both starting with lyrics and creating a melody are valid approaches to songwriting. The most important thing is to write and not give up on your passion. Songwriting is not about fame or financial gain, but rather the sheer joy and fulfillment of creating something beautiful. Whatever the circumstances, embrace the process and enjoy the journey.

So, dear songwriter, let the inspiration strike and the crafting of your masterpiece begin. Here’s to all those who share the love of music and the art of songwriting!