Does Every Companion Have to Be Human in Doctor Who?

Throughout its captivating run, the popular sci-fi series Doctor Who has showcased a diverse range of companions alongside its time-traveling protagonist. These companions have varied in form and origin, including both humans and non-humans. Some non-human companions were even visually indistinguishable from humans, adding to the rich tapestry of the show. This article delves into the question of whether every companion in Doctor Who has to be human, exploring the reasons behind this choice and the diverse forms of companions that the Doctor has had over the years.

Exploring Non-Human Companions

The Doctor has journeyed with many companions who are not from Earth or are not entirely human. Some examples include:

Susan Forester (Gallifreyan): Susan, the first regular companion to the Doctor, was from Gallifrey, a homeworld of the Time Lords. She was a traditional companion in every sense, but the show acknowledges the cultural differences between humans and Gallifreyans. Romana I (Gallifreyan): Another Gallifreyan, Romana I was a prominent companion who further expanded the concept of what a Time Lord could be. She contributed significantly to the show's mythology, particularly with her connection to the Type 40 TARDIS. Adric (Human): Kayadun Adric, a human male, was one of the first non-human companions. Adric's father was human, and his mother was a Hwati—a small humanoid race. This unique origin brought a fresh perspective to the Doctor's team. Nyssa (Trakenite): Another non-human companion, Nyssa was from the planet Traken, known for its tragic history of psychic ability. Her presence in the TARDIS provided a sense of alienity alongside the relatable human companions like Tegan. K-9 (Robotic Companion): While K-9 was a robot, his robotic nature contributed to the mix of companions. K-9 was an intelligent and loyal robot, initially interacting with the Doctor before becoming Tegan Jürriksen's companion. His electronic nature and artificial intelligence added a technological edge to the companionship dynamic. Kamelion (Robotic Companion): Kamelion was a rare but significant robotic companion. His ability to take on human forms made him a unique member of the Doctor's crew, often interacting with the characters and contributing to the narrative in unique ways.

Why Avoid Using Alien Makeup?

While it's arguable that every companion has to be human, practical considerations often play a significant role in the decision-making process. A primary reason for choosing human or near-human companions is the need to continue casting regular actors. Days, months, and years of filming and interaction with the Doctor and other characters require human actors to maintain a consistent appearance, regardless of their on-screen form. Employing alien makeup for extended periods can be challenging and impractical, both from an artistic and logistical standpoint. The realistic human facade of these companions makes it easier for the audience to connect and form a relationship with them.

The Importance of Diversity

Despite the convenience of human companions, the show's writers have worked hard to diversify the companions, bringing in non-human, non-humans, and even cyborgs. This diversity in companions contributes to the overall richness of the show's storytelling. Non-human companions not only add a new dimension to the Doctor's friendship but also present unique situations and challenges, enriching the narrative and providing a broader range of experiences for the audience.

Conclusion

The question of whether every companion must be human in Doctor Who is an intriguing one. While it is not necessary, practical and creative reasons influence the choices made by the show's writers. The inclusion of various non-human companions has added depth and diversity to the series, making it one of the most beloved and enduring works of science fiction. As Doctor Who continues to evolve, we can expect more interesting and diverse companions to join the Doctor's adventures, further expanding the rich history and mythology of the show.