Does Age Really Matter in a Presidential Candidate Like Trump or Biden?

The age of a presidential candidate is often a topic of debate. Critics argue that older candidates might not be as mentally competent as their younger counterparts. However, it's the mental competence of a leader that truly matters, regardless of age.

Age vs. Mental Competence

The focus should be on a candidate's mental state and overall competence rather than their age. Both Donald Trump and Joe Biden have had unique but critically important roles in American politics. While both have reached advanced ages, their mental health and mental competence are crucial factors for voters to consider.

Mental Tests and Public Accountability

It might be beneficial for both candidates to take mental tests and publicly disclose the results. For instance, in a case where a court ordered a mental health evaluation, like in the Merchan case, it suggests that the candidate is aware of their mental stability. This transparency can help quell doubts among the public and enhance their credibility.

The Diversity of Aging

When looking at families, you may observe that different members age in unique ways. For example, Trump remains vibrant and can speak for hours off the cuff with no script. In contrast, Biden's fast aging process makes him seem more like a candidate of his past self rather than his present capabilities.

Character and Competence Over Age

While age is not a decisive factor, character and competence are paramount. These qualities can be subjective but are easier to assess by examining a candidate’s historic accomplishments in politics.

Presidents with limited political experience have often struggled to fulfill their roles. Politicians like Hoover, Eisenhower, Grant, and Taylor had histories of dealing with or without a chain of command, which didn't always translate well to the presidency. These individuals, who were ex-Generals, had some experience in leadership, but none had faced the complexities of being the head of state.

Donald Trump, with a background in business rather than politics, has had a controversial record. He has faced numerous accusations of impulsive business decisions and has a history of prioritizing his personal interests over those of his stakeholders. This kind of leadership style raises questions about his ability to lead a country effectively.

It is also important to note that both Trump and Biden are old. This is not inherently a problem, as there are many successful leaders in their 80s. However, if either candidate was significantly younger, it might have been a cause for concern. This transparency is necessary to ensure that voters have accurate information about a candidate's mental state and leadership capabilities.

The debate over age in presidential candidates should not overshadow the importance of mental competence and character. By focusing on these critical factors, voters can make more informed decisions that prioritize the long-term stability and success of the country.