Do Secular Turks Like 'Erturul Series'?

The popularity of the 'Erturul' series among secular Turks is a topic of debate. Interestingly, this series has become a conversation starter, especially within the Latin American community where a Turkish enthusiast met a girl who is a fan of the show. This raises questions about the perception of the series among different segments of Turkish society.

Secular vs. Religious: A Cultural Perspective

In Turkey, the principle of secularism is deeply ingrained, with the constitution stating, 'Turkish Republic is a Secular Democratic and Social Constitutional State.' Thus, when discussing 'Erturul,' it is crucial to differentiate between 'secular' and 'religious' instead of referring to secularism as a term that can be misused.

Historical Context and Initial Reception

Many secular Turks have enjoyed the first series of 'Erturul' about Hurrem Sultan, which was praised for its great cast, high quality, and historical accuracy. While the 'Erturul' series has gained popularity, its subsequent seasons have not met the same level of enthusiasm among secular Turks due to its more nationalistic and religious tone. This has led to both surprise and disappointment when it comes to the show's mass appeal.

Reasons for Inconsistency in Reception

Secular Turks generally prefer shows such as 'Game of Thrones,' reflecting a preference for high production value and intricate storytelling. One reason for the lukewarm reception of the 'Erturul' series is the low production quality and scriptwriting. Here are the key issues that contribute to this:

Production Values and Artistry

Production Values: The series struggles with extremely low production values, making it less appealing. Acting and Directing: The acting and directing in the series are often criticized for their poor quality. Scriptwriting: The dialogue and scriptwriting are often described as subpar (C-class).

In addition, the sets and characters are described as being extremely dull, lacking the creativity and attention to detail that could have elevated the overall experience. The lack of a proper cinematography further diminishes the viewing experience, with repetitive and uncreative camera angles and a visibly lacking experience and professionalism.

Nationalism vs. Historical Accuracy

The series' heavy reliance on nationalism and religious themes has made it less appealing to secular viewers. The context of the series is centered on religious conflicts, which can be off-putting for those who seek more neutral and historical production. This does not negate the historical significance of the period, but it does make the series less interesting for those who prefer a more balanced and accurate representation.

Conclusion

While the 'Erturul' series holds historical importance and has its fan base, its reception among secular Turks is predominantly unenthusiastic due to its low production standards, unrealistic portrayal, and nationalistic tone. Its poor execution, especially in terms of artistic expression and historical accuracy, has led to a polarized audience. However, a high-quality, realistic, and neutral production would certainly cater to a broader audience and maintain the integrity of the historical narrative.