Disappointing Character Development in the Marvel Cinematic Universe
The Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) is renowned for its compelling character arcs and growth through its numerous films. While characters undergo significant transformations, some have experienced disappointing development, especially when it comes to Bruce Banner, commonly known as the Hulk. Let's delve into why the narrative trajectory of Bruce Banner/ Hulky has been a subject of critique and discussion among fans and critics alike.
Character Arc vs. Character Growth
First, we must distinguish between character arcs and growth. Character arcs are about transformation and the journey a character takes, while growth typically refers to an advancement in a character’s journey towards a positive or more well-rounded version of themselves. In terms of specific growth within the MCU, Bruce Banner/ Hulky has been a prime example of a missed opportunity for more substantial development.
Bruce Banner and His Journey
Bruce Banner, first introduced in Marvel: The Avengers, is a character with a complex transformation. A brilliant scientist who developed the super-soldier formula as a healing agent for a beloved soldier, Bruce's story revolves around his secret identity, which comes to light after an accident in Iron Man 2. In the Avengers, Bruce proves his worth as a key member of the team, showcasing his intelligence and combat skills, culminating in a cathartic moment where he unleashes the Hulk and successfully saves the world.
By the time of Age of Ultron, Bruce's character development hits a sore spot. Joss Whedon's choice to portray Bruce as less confident and in control of the Hulk disrupts the narrative established in the previous film. Bruce is sidelined, and instead of being the pivotal figure, his role is diminished, with even the Hulk being relied upon more heavily to save the day. His character's potential to evolve into a well-rounded superhero is squandered.
Bruce Banner in Later Installments
Fast-forward to Thor: Ragnarok. Taika Waititi, while bringing refreshing humor to the Hulk, further isolates Bruce. His character is sidelined for humor, reducing him to a supporting role, and even his interactions with the Hulk fail to enrich his own character. His motivations and desires are sidelined, with his role in the story being incidental and overshadowed. This leaves Bruce's character arc in a state of disarray, with his potential for growth stifled.
However, in Infinity War, there is a bit of a resurgence. The Russo brothers introduce a narrative where Bruce's character is re-examined, emphasizing his role as a hero without the Hulk. The film does highlight his struggle and contributions to the team, yet this development is somewhat overshadowed by the overwhelming focus on the Hulk and the overall conflict with Thanos. Bruce remains a character in a state of flux, his journey put on hold.
The Bottom Line
The disappointment in Bruce Banner's growth stems from several factors, primarily the inconsistent portrayal of his character throughout the MCU films. Each director has introduced their own narrative that, in some cases, overshadows or outright contradicts the previous one, particularly concerning his relationship with the Hulk. While there have been instances of positive growth, such as in Avengers: Age of Ultron, the overall trajectory of his character remains underwhelming, failing to capture the full potential of the character's narrative journey.
Ultimately, Bruce Banner/ Hulky's character development has been a mix of missed opportunities and inconsistent effort, leading to a less satisfying journey for both fans and critics. The MCU would do well to maintain a consistent narrative thread that can truly define and develop this complex and fascinating superhero.