Do Star Trek Fans Get Defensive When Someone Criticises the Franchise?
Being a fan of Star Trek for over four decades, I have observed that while some fans become defensive when someone critically evaluates the franchise, many remain open and respectful. It's important to recognize that there is room for critique without descending into disrespectful dialogue.
Defensiveness Amongst Fans
My wife once expressed her frustration with the older series, questioning why we couldn't watch something new like TNG without the Professor X episode. But I've heard others saying 'What's the difference?' and 'There is no difference.' This lack of appreciation for the evolution within the franchise is evident, particularly with newer series like Doctor Who and its Scottish portrayal.
Respectful Critique vs. Rude Discourse
Many discussions in modern society lack respect, as individuals are prone to making biased remarks. Saying 'Star Trek sucks and people who like it are stupid' is disrespectful and offers no value. Genuine criticism should be well-thought-out and aimed at sparking productive conversation. Everyone deserves respect, even when they criticize the things we hold dear.
Acceptance and Light-hearted Critique
Most fans are enlightened enough to recognize the spontaneity and silliness of certain Star Trek aspects, often engaging in light-hearted criticism and joking about them. However, ridiculing fellow fans solely because they enjoy the show comes across as bullying. It's unnecessary and indecent, as those who do this lack knowledge about the franchise. Like avoiding a discussion on sports or pop music, ridiculing others is disrespectful and unwelcome.
The Prime Directive in Fan Behavior
Just as the Prime Directive in Star Trek calls for non-interference and respect for alien cultures, fans should practice similar principles in their discourse. Disagreeing about a show's quality or plot points is okay, but one must refrain from picking fights or being argumentative. For instance, while I may not appreciate the J.J. Abrams Star Trek movies except for the first one, I would not bring up my opinion if my friend enjoyed them. Remember, it's a vast universe, and there is plenty of space for everyone.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while some fans may become defensive when criticized, it's essential to maintain respectful and critical discourse. One must be aware of their own biases and engage in conversations that promote mutual respect and understanding. This approach ensures a harmonious community where everyone can appreciate the beauty and depth of Star Trek.