Understanding Clara's Lasting Impact: What Clara Says to the Doctor in the Cloisters

The mystery of what Clara Oswald says to the Doctor in the Cloisters has been a subject of intense speculation among fans and scholars alike. While Steven Moffat, the mastermind behind these enigmatic scenes, chooses to keep his cards close to his chest, it's crucial to delve into the previous narrative to understand the context. This article explores the significance of Clara's final words, explaining why they are so profound and what they might imply about the Doctor's feelings.

The Context: Clara's Departure

In the episode 'Face the Raven," a poignant scene unfolds just before Clara steps into harm's way. She says to the Doctor:

[Everything you're about to say I already know. Don't do it now. We've already had bad timing.]

These words encapsulate the deep connection and shared destiny between Clara and the Doctor. By warning him not to speak, Clara is aware that his words might bring more pain than relief. She understands that their last moments together could be devastating, especially considering her impending death. Moffat hints at the gravity of what the Doctor might have shared, suggesting it could involve a deeply romantic or emotional declaration.

The Doctor's Intentions

The Cloisters scene itself reveals the Doctor's willingness to go to great lengths to protect Clara. In a process that could be seen as a form of extended goodbye, he demands the human-compatible memory-wiper to ensure her safety from the Raven. This act is a testament to the depth of his love and the complexity of their relationship. The Doctor, who had spent countless centuries mourning Clara's death, was willing to endure further anguish for her sake. This willingness aligns with the prophecy in the 'Face the Raven' text, where the hybrid is described as 'destroy a billion billion hearts to heal his own.'

Absent but Present: The Impact of Clara's Silence

Steven Moffat has often referred to these scenes as 'white noise', indicating that the exact words Clara and the Doctor exchanged are not on the script. However, we can infer a lot about their relationship from the context.

The Doctor's actions, particularly his demand for the memory-wiper, demonstrate how much Clara meant to him. It shows that he was prepared to bear the pain of heartbreak and the loss of their relationship for her sake. The memory-wiper can be seen as an act of self-sacrifice; to erase Clara's memories of him while he himself carries the burden of the pain.

Conclusion: The Complexity of Their Bond

Clara and the Doctor's relationship is complex, involving both physical and emotional aspects. The Doctor's decision to ensure Clara's safety, even at the cost of his own suffering, speaks volumes about his feelings. Whether Clara conveyed her love, respect, or something else to the Doctor in the Cloisters, her words were undoubtedly profound and deeply felt. The exact nature of these words remains a mystery, but their impact on the characters and the broader narrative of Doctor Who is undeniable.

While we may never know the exact words Clara and the Doctor exchanged, the context reveals a love that transcends time and space. The Doctor's actions in the Cloisters demonstrate his profound understanding of the importance of Clara's happiness and safety. Even in the absence of explicit dialogue, these hidden moments contribute immensely to the depth and richness of the Doctor Who universe.