Can Thanos or Any Villain Carry and Throw Thor While He's Holding Mjolnir?

The question of whether Thanos or any other villain can carry and throw Thor while he's holding Mjolnir has fascinated Marvel enthusiasts for years. This discussion delves into the physics and magic behind Mjolnir, exploring different scenarios and breaking down the key points.

Understanding the Enchantment of Mjolnir

At the core of this debate is the magical property of Mjolnir. According to the lore, Mjolnir carries a unique enchantment that only allows those deemed worthy to lift it. Thor, being worthy, can wield the hammer without issues. However, what happens when this enchantment is in play?

The Role of Physical Contact

The key to whether Thanos or any other villain can carry and throw Thor while he's holding Mjolnir lies in physical contact with the hammer. If nobody touches Mjolnir, even a stronger foe like Thanos might be able to hold or throw Thor effectively. However, the moment someone touches the hammer, Mjolnir's enchantment kicks back into effect, nullifying any efforts to lift or carry it.

Gravity Magic in Mjolnir

The gravity magic in Mjolnir is one of the most intriguing aspects of the weapon's lore. Once Thor wields it, the enchantment disables the gravity magic, making it heavy or light depending on the individual's worthiness. This explains why Thor and Captain America can lift it, while others cannot. Therefore, Thanos, despite his immense strength, would still be unable to lift Mjolnir once it is in Thor's grip.

Physical Constraints and Examples

Examples from movies and comics further support this idea. In Thor: Ragnarok, during the initial scene where Thor is inside the dragon's mouth (or rather a rocket-powered helldog), the dragon can hold Thor and Mjolnir easily as long as Thor does not let go of the hammer. Only when Thor releases Mjolnir does the dragon struggle to move, highlighting the significance of the hammer's enchantment.

Similarly, Thor has been thrown or knocked back several times while holding Mjolnir. In the Avengers film, Thor attempted to use Mjolnir against the Hulk, but the enchantment proved ineffective, and Thor was defeated. This scenario illustrates that Mjolnir's enchantment only provides effect when the hammer is stationary or summoned.

The Effect of Wielders on Mjolnir

In the context of wielding the hammer, the enchantment only affects those directly holding it. Hence, if someone else has Mjolnir, any villain can lift and carry Thor without much issue. The only caveat is that the villain must not touch the hammer for this to work.

For instance, in Thor: The Dark World, Kurse, a strong being, knocked Mjolnir aside despite it being summoned by Thor. This demonstrates that the enchantment can be overridden by a powerful individual's strength.

Conclusion

To summarize, while Thanos and other villains cannot pick up Mjolnir, they can carry and potentially throw Thor while he's holding the hammer. The key is the physical separation of Mjolnir from anyone touching it. Whether this situation would play out in a real battle scenario remains to be seen, but it's clear that the enchantment of Mjolnir adds a unique layer of complexity to the Marvel universe.

Related Links

Mjolnir on LEGO Marvel Mjolnir on Marvel Fandom Thor and Mjolnir on Avengers Fandom

Keywords

Mjolnir, Thor, Avengers, Loki's staff, LEGO Marvel