Can Actors Win Multiple Oscars for the Same Role?

The field of acting faces numerous rules and practices designed to maintain fairness and integrity in the Academy Awards. One of the most remarkable instances of an actor being nominated for the same role in multiple films is rare, but not impossible. For the record, it has happened, and we will delve into the history of actors who have accomplished this feat.

Barry Fitzgerald: A Noteworthy Case

Decades ago, Barry Fitzgerald battled for recognition in the film industry. In the movie 'Going My Way,' Fitzgerald faced a unique dilemma. He was nominated for both Best Actor and Best Supporting Actor. The rules, however, allowed for such a scenario in the past, and he won the Best Supporting Actor award.

His co-star, Bing Crosby, won the Best Actor award, but Fitzgerald's performance in the supporting role was notable. This historic event set a precedent for future rules, which changed to prevent such dual nominations in the future.

The Historic 1947 Oscar Win

The year 1947 marked a significant milestone in the Academy Awards history. William Wyler's film 'The Best Years of Our Lives' won a total of seven competitive awards. Among the recipients were Harold Russell, who won an Academy Award for his role as the character Homer Parish, and the film's director, William Wyler.

Harrison Ford played the role of Lieutenant Randy Scully in 'The Air Force Story' in 1955 and later reprised the role in 'Where Eagles Dare' in 1968. He was nominated for an Oscar for Best Actor in 'The Air Force Story' but did not receive an Oscar when the role was later played in 'Where Eagles Dare.'

Harold Russell: A Pioneering Actor

Harold Russell stands out as the only actor to have won multiple Oscars for the same role. He won a Best Supporting Actor Oscar for his role in 'The Best Years of Our Lives' in 1946 and an Honorary Oscar, which was presented as a special honor. This case is unique because Russell was a real-life disabled veteran, and his character, Homer Parish, was based on himself.

Harold Russell was not expected to win the award but ultimately did. However, he faced a financial crisis and had to sell the Oscar to pay for his wife's medical bills. Lew Wasserman, the head of Universal Studios, later donated the award back to the Academy.

Cate Blanchett: An Example of Multiple Nominations

Cate Blanchett is an example of an actress who has been nominated for the same role in different films. She was nominated for an Oscar for her portrayal of Queen Elizabeth I in 'Elizabeth' in 1999 and again for her role in 'Elizabeth: The Golden Age' in 2008. However, she did not win in either category.

Al Pacino: Double Nomination for the Same Character

It's also possible for an actor to be nominated for the same character in multiple films but in different roles. A clear example of this is Al Pacino, who was nominated for Best Actor in 'The Godfather' and 'The Godfather Part II' for his role as Michael Corleone.

Conclusion

The history of the Oscars showcases a few unique instances where actors were nominated or won multiple awards for the same role. While these occurrences are rare, they highlight the exceptional talent of the actors involved and the evolving nature of the industry's rules.

References

Images from: