CLC vs GI-DLE: The Impact of Luck on K-pop Groups Under Cube Entertainment

The Korean entertainment industry, known for its highly competitive market, constantly highlights the power of luck. Among the diverse roster of Cube Entertainment, two groups, CLC and GI-DLE, stand out for their varying fortunes. This article delves into the challenges faced by these groups, analyzing the impact of luck on their journeys.

The Challenges Faced by Cube Groups

Both CLC and GI-DLE have had their share of struggles under Cube Entertainment, leading to a discussion on which one has worse luck.

CLC's Challenges

Disbandment: CLC faced significant challenges, including a lack of promotional support and a gradual decline in activity. Despite having strong talent and potential, they struggled to gain the same level of popularity as other groups from Cube.

Member Issues: The group had a shifting lineup, with some members leaving or not being utilized effectively. This affected their cohesion and public visibility. These factors culminated in the eventual disbandment of the group.

Final Release: Their last release marked the end of an era for the group, with no significant promotion or follow-up material to sustain their fanbase.

GI-DLE's Challenges

Initial Success: GI-DLE debuted in 2018 and quickly gained popularity, thanks to hits like 'XXX.' However, their journey was not without challenges, and they faced several hurdles as well.

Resilience: Despite controversies and other issues, GI-DLE has shown remarkable resilience. They continued to release successful music and maintained a strong fanbase post-Soojin's departure. Their ability to come back strong after adversity is a testament to the group's spirit.

Luck and Luckiness

While CLC faced more severe setbacks leading to disbandment and limited opportunities, GI-DLE navigated their issues more effectively to remain active in the industry. One could argue that CLC had worse luck overall, given their disbandment and lack of support, while GI-DLE has managed to overcome their challenges.

Further Insights: The Treatment of Cube Groups

It seems that CLC has consistently faced the brunt of unfair treatment compared to other groups under Cube Entertainment, a trend observed across multiple instances.

Cube’s Proprietary Decisions

Lack of Promotions: GI-DLE, for instance, went on to perform on the survival show ‘QUEENDOM,’ which helped them gain a significant following. In contrast, CLC hasn’t done any major survival shows, with the only exception being Yujin’s participation in 'Girls Planet 999.'

Album Releases and Hiatuses: The frequency and publicity of their albums highlight another area where CLC seems to have been overlooked. GI-DLE’s consistent presence and active comeback schedule have undoubtedly contributed to their sustained popularity.

The Orginal Versatility of 'La Vie En Rose'

Moreover, it is worth noting that 'La Vie En Rose' was initially intended to be a CLC song. They had recorded all the parts before the decision was made to gift the song to IZONE, leaving CLC with 'NO.' This example underscores the complex decisions and prioritizations within Cube Entertainment.

Conclusion

The comparison between CLC and GI-DLE under Cube Entertainment reveals a stark contrast in their experiences and luck. While GI-DLE has managed to overcome numerous challenges, CLC’s journey has been marked by significant setbacks. These examples illustrate the role of luck in the K-pop industry and the importance of support systems in group success.