Australian Commandos versus the SASR: An Elite Comparison

When it comes to elite military units in Australia, both the Commandos and the Special Air Service Regiment (SASR) are at the top of the list. But how do they compare? The question often comes up among service members and enthusiasts alike. Whether a commando or an SASR Trooper, perspectives can be highly subjective, leading to debates and even running jokes within the community.

Perceptions from Within and Without

Interestingly, perceptions of one unit’s elite status can vary greatly between members of different units. If you ask a commando, the answer is often a resounding yes. However, if you ask an SASR Trooper, the answer may depend on who is asking. Both units are recognized for their exceptional training, expertise, and courage. This recognition has led to some unique interactions, such as the running joke among SASR Troopers that goes something like, 'The SASR is what Commandos want to join when they grow up.' Such remarks reflect the mutual respect and high standards required by both units.

Notable Criticisms and Controversies

Mark Donaldson, a former SASR member, has written extensively about his critical views on the conduct and professionalism of the Commandos. In his book, 'The Crossroads,' he highlights a particularly controversial incident. Donaldson criticized the use of explosives to blow open a door, which was unacceptable to the SASR troopers. This action not only exposed them to enemy gunfire but also highlighted the differences in approach and methodology between the two units. Such incidents serve as a stark reminder of the nuanced nature of these units and the need for continuous evaluation and improvement within the military.

Contemporary Roles and Performance

Regardless of the occasional disagreements and criticisms, both the Commandos and the SASR continue to perform their duties with distinction. The Australian commandos, known for their intelligence operations and unconventional warfare, and the SASR, renowned for their counter-terror and special forces capabilities, are often called upon to serve in overseas missions. Their effectiveness is not a matter of who is more elite but rather a testament to their rigorous training, unwavering dedication, and ability to adapt to any situation.

Conclusion: The Importance of Mutual Respect and Continuous Improvement

In the end, the debate about whether the Commandos or the SASR are more elite is less about achieving a definitive answer and more about the mutual respect and recognition within the military community. Both units share a common goal: to upholding the highest standards of professionalism and bravery. As they continue to face new challenges and threats, the importance of continuous improvement and mutual understanding will remain critical.