Art That Challenges: What Is Strange or Disturbing?
Introduction
Art that defies societal norms or explores unconventional themes often leaves viewers with a mixture of reactions, ranging from fascination to discomfort. This article explores the subjective nature of art, delving into the viewpoints of those who find it challenging to accept the strange or even disturbing aspects of art. We will also examine the fascinating relationship between art and the emotional well-being of its most enigmatic practitioners.
What Is Strange or Disturbing about Art?
While some might find certain works of art strange, unsettling, or even disturbing, the late art critic and author, Janet Kardon, argued that these reactions are often a product of personal and cultural biases. Kardon emphasizes that what one finds disturbing could be viewed as powerful or thought-provoking by another individual. She posits that viewers often confront their own beliefs and emotions, pushing boundaries and fostering introspection.
Upon reflection, I do not find much that is truly strange or disturbing in art. There is a wide range of perspectives and opinions, all shaped by subjective and objective factors. These include personal tastes and preferences, one's current mood and state of mind, cultural context, exposure, learning, and understanding of the technical aspects of art.
Subjectivity in Art
My own reactions to art are influenced by a combination of these factors. While I may have a particular affinity for some artworks and indifference towards others, I rarely find them strange. In an increasingly interconnected world, exposure to a diverse range of styles, forms, and approaches is commonplace. What may appear strange to one person might simply be another form of artistic expression or a marketing tactic. Each individual has their own perspective and there is no one-size-fits-all answer to the question of what is strange in art.
Concerning disturbing art, I have come to accept that all forms of art can be valid. Having experienced a substantial portion of life’s challenges, I find that most art, including pieces designed to evoke strong emotional reactions, is not truly disturbing. There is an emotional component, but it is often more of an unpleasant feeling rather than a deeply disturbing one.
The Psychological Impact on Artistic Practitioners
Kay Redfield Jamison, a leading clinical psychologist at the National Institute of Mental Health, has extensively studied mood disorders in creative individuals, especially writers and poets. She noted that 38% of writers and poets received treatment for mood disorders, with 89% of creative writers and artists experiencing them at some point in their lives. Jamison’s work underscores the commonalities between the psychological experiences of artists and those in various other fields.
Life Through the Lens of a Creative
Having lived and worked closely with creative individuals, primarily writers, over the first half of my adult life, I can empathize with the emotional toll of artistic expression. Many of the most gifted practitioners find themselves emotionally unable to cope with the rigors of a challenging world. This is not an uncommon occurrence, and it highlights the delicate balance between creativity and mental well-being.
Art can be a dangerous calling, bringing both immense joy and profound pain. For those who push the boundaries of what is socially acceptable, the cost can be significant. Emotional resilience is often required to navigate the ‘artistic grind,’ the intense and often tumultuous process of creation.
It is understandable for individuals to need to detach themselves from the intense and often tumultuous artistic environment. The pressures of creative work can sometimes feel overwhelming, leading to burnout. Some artists resort to removing themselves from the situation to maintain their mental health and well-being.
Conclusion
The subjective nature of art makes it subjective. What one person may find strange or disturbing is another’s source of inspiration and thought-provoking insight. The artistic community is a diverse and complex one, where the truest form of artwork often stems from the most profound emotional experiences.
While the psychological impact of art on its practitioners is significant, it is important to view this phenomenon with understanding and empathy. Art is a reflection of human emotion and thought, and the struggles faced by its creators can lead to some of the most profound and impactful works of our time.