Could Andy García Have Revived the Godfather Franchise?

Could Garcia Have Carried On the Godfather Series?

The idea of Andy García taking over as the new Godfather is fascinating, but it’s doubtful. García was an accomplished actor, but it’s worth analyzing whether he could have carried on the legacy of The Godfather trilogy while making it his own.

What Garcia Could Have Done

The concept of Guy Garcia becoming the CGI Don who climbs up walls in a series of barely distinguishable 43 films is intriguing but unrealistic. Instead, a more likely scenario would involve a new story arc, perhaps focusing on the generation that followed Michael Corleone.

García might have portrayed Vincent Corleone, the successor to Michael, but the franchise had already run its course by the third movie. The audience and critics were so put off by The Godfather Part III that it took a while for people to want to see more. The series had fewer opportunities for compelling storytelling beyond Vincent taking over for his grandfather.

The Character of Vincent Corleone

Andy García could have played Vincent Corleone, but the role would be vastly different from Michael. Vincent is more prone to drinking, and he loses Mary, which puts a strain on him earlier than Michael. He misses the days when he could easily wield a gun and kill an enemy, but he understands and values family.

With family advice from Connie, Vincent navigates the more legitimate path his uncle pursued. The deal with Immobiliare keeps the family in business, but it comes with its own challenges. The police eventually discover illegal activities on the real estate properties owned by Immobiliare, which could have led to a dramatic and fitting conclusion for the franchise.

The Limit of Garcia’s Potential in Reviving the Franchise

While Andy García could have carried the Godfather series for one more film, the fourth would have to be the final chapter. Vincent Corleone, much like his father Sonny, would have struggled with stability and intelligence. His reign would likely have led to the downfall of the Corleone family in a big, explosive way.

Despite his talent and potential, García’s portrayal of Vincent would have been a grim and inevitable end to the series. The unconventional and unstable nature of Vincent would have contributed to the demise of the Corleone legacy, making it a memorable and impactful conclusion to the franchise.