Analysis of Reused Concepts in the Sequel Trilogy: A Comparative Study of 'Star Wars'
When examining the sequel trilogy of Star Wars, a striking phenomenon emerges: the re-use of ideas and concepts from the prequel and original trilogies. This article delves into these recurrent elements, comparing them to the original trilogy and analyzing their significance in the current sequels.
Character Archetypes and Plot Clichés
The introduction of the main protagonist is a prime example of familiar tropes re-cooked from earlier trilogies. In both the original and prequel trilogies, we see protagonists who grew up on uneventful, remote planets and embarked on an adventurous journey, such as Luke Skywalker on Tatooine or Rey on Jakku. This narrative setup is mirrored in the sequels, with Rey sharing a similar backstory of a humble life on a desert planet, followed by an exciting leap into the cosmos.
Supporting Elements and Supporting Characters
The scrapheap Millenium Falcon, a symbol of freedom and escape, also appears in the original trilogy, inspiring audiences with its ragtag appearance and functional charm. In the sequel trilogy, Rey's journey involves a step into a similar vehicle, reinforcing the familiar notion of a reluctant hero finding solace in an old and trusted vessel.
The seductive yet sinister main antagonists also recur, wearing black robes and masks, reminiscent of Darth Vader and Kylo Ren's designs. This consistent visual identity emphasizes the dichotomy between light and dark forces, reinforcing the central theme of the franchise.
Galactic Flaws and Narrative Repetition
The narrative often draws parallels between the forces at play in the original and new trilogies. The galactic organization depicted in the revised trilogies is heavily influenced by the framework of the Galactic Empire, with similar aesthetic elements such as wedgeshaped capital ships, H-shaped fighters, and troopers in white armor. This reiteration not only provides a familiar sense of continuity but also underlines the cyclical nature of power struggles within the galaxy.
Key Sequences and Spaceship Combat
The sequence of X-wings flying through a trench to hit a crucial weakpoint of the space station is a nod to the iconic Battle of Yavin. However, in the sequel trilogy, this trope has been modernized with the introduction of Starkiller Base, a colossal weapon capable of planet-killing capabilities. Despite the renewed scale and technological sophistication, the core concept remains the same, serving as a pivotal moment of drama and heroism in each respective trilogy.
Training and Mentorship
Another recurring theme is the training of the protagonist in Jedi ways. In the original trilogy, Luke Skywalker training with Yoda is a hallmark of the series. In the sequels, Rey seeks training from Luke, continuing the mentorship dynamic. However, the sequels also introduce a new form of this narrative, with Rey training under the guidance of a hermit Jedi, setting a different tone and archetype for the training sequence.
Caricature and Parody
The portrayal of the dark side apprentice killing their master is another recurring motif. This sequence, seen in the prequels with Anakin's fall to the dark side and in the sequel trilogy with Kylo Ren's descent, serves as a critical turning point in the story, marking the protagonist's moral struggle and the inevitability of the dark side's influence.
Conclusion and Final Thoughts
The re-use of ideas and concepts in the sequel trilogy is a complex narrative strategy. While some elements may be forgivable, such as the similarities to the Empire's aesthetics and the recurring theme of Jedi becoming a myth, others, like the ridiculous re-use of old concepts such as Starkiller Base, may seem incongruous within the established universe. These reiterations serve both to cement the franchise's legacy and to offer new and familiar storylines to long-time fans and newcomers alike.
As Star Wars continues to evolve, the debate around these recurring themes will likely persist, offering a rich field of analysis for both critics and fans alike.