An In-Depth Analysis of the Movie 'Surgical Strike': A Blend of Art and Reality
The much-discussed movie 'Surgical Strike' has been a subject of both praise and criticism, dividing opinions sharply. With a rating of 3/5, the film has drawn mixed reactions, particularly regarding its visual storytelling, accuracy, and the portrayal of the Indian army.
Visual Storytelling and Cinematography
The film's cinematography is widely appreciated, and it has been hailed as a milestone in Indian filmmaking. Director and cinematographer receive commendations for their ability to capture the essence of the mission visually. Cinematic shots of the Indian army unfold in a manner that gives a sense of realism and maturity to the film, making it resonate with a broader audience.
One of our friends, who has an army background, was particularly impressed with the depiction of the army party in the film. The humanization of the soldiers, who are often depicted as superhuman in real life, is a commendable aspect of the movie. This portrayal helps viewers understand the emotions and struggles of the personnel involved, thus adding depth to the narrative.
Factual Inaccuracies and Suspension of Disbelieve
While the cinematography and visual storytelling are praiseworthy, the film's portrayal of certain aspects of the surgical strike mission has been heavily criticized. Several factual inaccuracies have raised eyebrows among viewers and critics.
For instance, the depiction of the army personnel growing beards, a practice which is not common in peacetime, has sparked a debate. Additionally, the portrayal of the mission's execution shows an infiltration via a network of caves and helicopters, which contradicts the official accounts. In reality, the team crossed over through land, though the details remain hazy due to the sensitive nature of the operation.
Another aspect that has been heavily criticized is the character of Yami Gautam attaching GPS tags to her mother's clothes. This is seen as a clichéd and anachronistic plot device, hinting at a lack of attention to detail and historical accuracy.
Conclusion and Perspective
Despite the factual inaccuracies, 'Surgical Strike' remains a commendable effort that highlights the commitment of the Indian army towards the nation. The film is not about glorifying the military or promoting jingoism; rather, it focuses on the dedication of the institution to its personnel and the nation.
For a factual account of the surgical strike, viewers are encouraged to watch the History TV18 episode featuring key stakeholders involved in the operation, including the then army chief, northern army commander, defense minister, and NSAB Doval, along with journalist Nitin Gokhale, who has extensive experience in national security reporting.
Key Takeaways:
1. The film's cinematography is a significant highlight, marking a new era in Indian filmmaking.
2. Praise for humanizing the army personnel, making them relatable and not portraying them as superhuman.
3. Factual inaccuracies, such as beards and the mission's execution, have been criticized, highlighting a need for attention to detail in such sensitive narratives.
Related Keywords:
Cinematography, Surgical Strike, Realism in Movies