Introduction

The Star Wars universe is vast and complex, rich with alternate realities and what-ifs. In a fascinating twist of history, what if Shmi Skywalker had died when Anakin was just 14, and he had learned of her fate on his own? This scenario would significantly alter the events of the films, potentially leading to a very different outcome and turning point in the story of the Jedi and the Sith.

Original Timeline

In the original Star Wars story, Anakin Skywalker's mother, Shmi Skywalker, is killed when Anakin is about to turn 14. This event leaves a profound impact on his life, leading him to the Jedi and eventually to the dark side. However, this article explores the possibility of a parallel universe where Shmi's death occurs under different circumstances, potentially leading to different outcomes.

Scenario One: Rage and Expulsion

In this hypothetical scenario, Anakin senses that his mother has died at a young age. Unable to control his emotions, his anger and grief cause him to act impulsively. This could lead to a severe reaction, potentially resulting in his expulsion from the Jedi Order. This would require a thorough explanation and justification from the Sith, most likely Count Dooku or Darth Sidious (Palpatine), as they are likely to exploit Anakin's chaos for their own plans.

Without the support and guidance of the Jedi, Anakin might find himself vulnerable and more susceptible to the influence of the dark side. This could lead to a faster and more dramatic descent into the Sith, setting the stage for an alternate version of Episode III: Revenge of the Sith. Palpatine would need to take on a much more active role in shaping Anakin's destiny, potentially creating a stronger and more calculating Sith.

Scenario Two: Sadness and Solitude

Alternatively, Anakin could discover the news of Shmi's death alongside other shocking revelations. Rather than erupting into rage, he might experience profound sadness and grief, leading him to isolate himself and the world he knew. This emotional state would make him less likely to engage in the Jedi Order's training and more inclined to seek solace or vengeance elsewhere.

Palpatine, recognizing this emotional turmoil, would need to work harder to turn the young Anakin. He might offer comfort and understanding, leading Anakin to seek a form of solace and direction from the Sith. The Sith's use of emotional manipulation would play a pivotal role in this scenario, ensuring that Anakin is emotionally vulnerable and more easily swayed. This could lead to a slower and more tactical transition to the dark side.

Impacts on the Cinematic Universe

Both of these scenarios would dramatically change the trajectory of the Star Wars narrative. In the first scenario, the aggressive response to Shmi's death could lead to a more explosive and chaotic revelation of the Sith's true intentions. This might prompt a more immediate confrontation between the Jedi and the Sith, leading to a faster resolution of the conflict.

In the second scenario, the slower progression of Anakin to the dark side would create a more complex and nuanced narrative. It could take longer for the conflict to escalate, allowing for more development of the characters and their relationships. This scenario might also lead to a more dramatic final showdown, as Anakin's journey would be more prolonged and more entangled with his personal losses.

Conclusion

The Star Wars universe is filled with endless possibilities, and scenarios like these illustrate just how pivotal a single event can be in shaping the destiny of a character and an entire galaxy. The death of Shmi Skywalker at a younger age when Anakin is 14 offers a fascinating exploration of what might have been. Whether Anakin's rage leads to expulsion or his sadness leads to isolation, both scenarios could rewrite the Star Wars saga in profound and dramatic ways. These what-ifs provide a fascinating look into the alternate realities that could exist within the vast Star Wars universe.