Alexander Hamilton in Hamilton: Demystifying the Misconception of Timidity

For many viewers of the critically acclaimed musical, Hamilton, the portrayal of Alexander Hamilton can be quite mystifying. Why is he depicted as someone timid and shy when in real life, he was anything but that?

The Misconception

The term 'timid' typically refers to someone who is shy, meek, or apprehensive. In the musical, Hamilton is often portrayed with a level of uncertainty and a softer demeanor. However, this portrayal presents a skewed version of the man he was.

According to the seminal piece in the show, 'Your Obedient Servant,' Hamilton's character explicitly states, 'I will not equivocate on my opinion / I have always worn it on my sleeve.' This line unequivocally demonstrates that Hamilton was not afraid to express his thoughts and opinions, regardless of what others might think.

A Bold and Uncompromising Spirit

Alexander Hamilton's life was marked by an abundance of courage and audacity. Born as a bastard child and orphan, he had to raise money to move to the mainland from a Caribbean island to seek education. His journey included obtaining a response from a wealthy family to marry, a move that was severely out of his financial league. He was not only bold in his personal choices but also in his public and political stance.

Hamilton is known for his public arguments with the President of the United States, George Washington, and Thomas Jefferson, the Secretary of State. These public disputes showcase his unyielding spirit and his unwavering commitment to his principles. Furthermore, he played a pivotal role in the formation of the United States by crafting the Federalist papers, a testament to his intellectual bravery and innovative spirit.

Misrepresentation in the Musical

There is a common misconception that Hamilton was timid during the final duel in the musical. However, this view is more nuanced. While Hamilton does hesitate for a moment before the duel, this hesitation is more accurately understood as contemplative courage rather than timidity. It takes immense courage to question whether it is justifiable to take another man's life when society has placed a clear expectation for revenge.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the portrayal of Alexander Hamilton as timid in the musical is a misrepresentation of his true character. Hamilton was a brave and resilient individual who faced numerous challenges throughout his life. Whether it was raising money to educate himself, marrying into wealth, or publicly debating influential figures, Hamilton's actions consistently demonstrate his courage and determination.

As one observer, Laurel, succinctly put it: 'Alexander was not timid!'

Alexander Hamilton, real life and in the musical, was one brave ass dude.