A Legendary Lineup of Rock Critics: Who's Your Top?

Rock criticism is an art form that has seen some of the most talented and influential writers in the history of journalism. Among the myriad of voices, a select few stand out as hallmarks of the genre. Not only have they left indelible marks through their work, but they have also inspired countless aspiring writers and music enthusiasts alike. This article aims to spotlight some of the most beloved and influential rock critics from the golden age of rock and beyond, taking inspiration from the personal experiences and influences of one journalist.

The Early Days of Musical Influence

My initial foray into the world of rock criticism was fueled by the writings in Rolling Stone and Creem magazines. These publications were brimming with passionate and honest reviews that often encompassed a multifaceted blend of cool, self-deprecating humor and the deadpan wit that made rock music commentary as entertaining as it was insightful. The camaraderie and personal touch in their articles served as a beacon for a young journalist like me, who looked up to these writers as not just heroes, but as mentors.

Ben Fong Torres: A Personal Hero

Ben Fong Torres stands prominently among my favorite rock critics. He is one of the most influential figures in the history of rock journalism, with his diverse background as a radio station apprentice in San Francisco and as part of a racially diverse group of role models, including Bruce Lee, Larry Ramos, Arnel Pineda, and Mike Inez. Ben's work as a critic and writer not only shaped the way I perceive rock music but also inspired me to pursue my own passion for journalism. His journey from a young radio apprentice to a renowned critic offers a unique and inspiring narrative.

Timed to the T's of Rock Journalism

The 1970s are often regarded as the heyday of rock journalism, marked by the emergence of influential critics who still resonate today. This was the decade when many of the rock critics mentioned in this piece gained prominence. Despite the magazine access not being readily available, my perspectives were piecemeal, and yet, the impressions left by these critics were profound and lasting.

Favorite Critics and Their Unique Styles

One of the most adored names among my favorites was Gregg Turner. Turner was not just a critic but also a member of a punk band called the Angry Samoans, adding a layer of authenticity and relatability to his work. Another standout was Richard Meltzer, whose collaboration with his college friend Sandy Pearlman as the lyricist for Blue Oyster Cult showcased his ability to blend music and writing seamlessly.

Robert Christgau: The Quintessential Critic

When it comes to succinctness, Robert Christgau shines. His ability to sum up an album review in just five words with his sharp wit and critical insight is unparalleled. This skill is exemplified in the famous scene from This Is Spinal Tap where Rob Reiner is interviewing the band, inadvertently referencing Christgau's minimalist approach to criticism. Despite not having the chance to read many Christgau's original articles, his online archive remains a treasure trove for aspiring journalists and music critics alike.

Notable Criticism Outlets from the Past

Creem and Crawdaddy were not just publications but gateways to a world of diverse and engaging voices. From Chet Flippo's contributions, which included a biography of Hank Williams Sr., to Robert Christgau's concise and insightful reviews, these magazines offered a rich tapestry of perspectives. The writings of Lester Bangs, Dave Marsh, and later Dave DiMartino, Bill Holdship, and John Kordosh consistently provided both entertainment and thought-provoking analysis. Kordosh's ability to inject humor in his writing made his pieces all the more engaging and memorable.

Conclusion: The Enduring Legacy of Rock Critics

The figures in rock criticism mentioned in this article have not only influenced the way I perceive music but have also set a benchmark for journalism. Their unique styles and perspectives continue to inspire and guide us in our pursuit of truth and passion in music. Whether we are looking at the legacy of Ben Fong Torres or the concise brilliance of Robert Christgau, these critics remind us of the enduring power of words in shaping our understanding and appreciation of rock music.