A Critical Analysis of the Star Wars Prequels: Better Storylines and Character Development

The Star Wars prequels, while beloved by many, have also faced criticism from fans and critics for their narrative choices and character development. This article delves into potential alternative storylines and character arcs that could have improved the quality and overall impact of the prequels. From changing the relationship between Padmé Amidala and Anakin Skywalker to reimagining key character arcs, we explore how these alterations could have enhanced the Star Wars saga.

Padmé Amiada Pursuant to Anakin Skywalker

One of the more significant criticisms of the prequels is the romantic and sometimes awkward relationship between Padmé and Anakin. A better storyline might have been reversing this dynamic, with Padmé pursuing Anakin instead. This would serve multiple purposes:

Sensitive Characterization: Padmé, portrayed by Natalie Portman, is a characterized as a well-respected Senator and mother, and her pursuit of a younger man who is still wrestling with issues of trust could have added depth and sensitivity to her character. Character Development: Anakin, on the other hand, might have been more relatable and less creepy if he were the one being pursed rather than doing the pursuing. His transition to the dark side could have been driven by a more complex and understandable love that is tragically thwarted. Tragic Consequence: The heartbreak and tragedy of losing a forbidden love could have made Anakin's fall to the dark side even more poignant, further emphasizing the consequences of his actions.

Enhanced Characterization of Anakin Skywalker

To counteract the stark differences between Anakin Skywalker in the prequels and the cartoon series, a more nuanced and subtle portrayal of his descent into darkness would have been beneficial. Here are some suggested alterations:

Subtle Darkness: Avoiding the blaring moments of Anakin's darkness like his execution of the Sand People. Instead, have a scene where Anakin interrogates someone too intensely, pushing the audience to question his actions. Thematic Integration: In Revenge of the Sith, reveal that Anakin has become a Jedi Knight who has secretly trained as a Sith, eventually culminating in his betrayal of the Jedi Order. This subterranean darkness would have provided more complexity to his character. Buddy Scenes: Strengthen the bond between Anakin and Obi-Wan by having more scenes where they are together. Early scenes in Attack of the Clones could set the stage for this relationship, reinforcing their trust and making Anakin's descent into the dark side even more impactful.

Additional Companions and Relationships

Adding additional strong relationships to complicate and drive Anakin's journey to the dark side could have been highly beneficial. Consider these suggestions:

Padmé and Obi-Wan Relationship: Padmé and Obi-Wan Kenobi could have a strong friendship with a Noble Kenobi including a hint of rivalry or jealousy from Anakin. Obi-Wan's obliviousness to this subtext could add layers of complexity to all three characters. Anakin's Sceptical Role: Casting Anakin as a more skeptical, rebellious figure like Han Solo would have provided a check and balance to his idealism. An older Anakin, perhaps around his late teens, could have brought more gravitas and depth to the role. Reimagining Darth Maul: Instead of Darth Maul being a one-movie villain, he could have been a recurring, increasingly sinister figure. Combining him with General Grievous into a single, formidable dark lord could have added tension to the trilogy.

Visual and Narrative Enhancements

To make the prequels more visually and narratively compelling, the following changes could have been made:

Better Aesthetic Integration: The prequels often feel out of place with the burgeoning New Jedi Order feels. A more cohesive visual and thematic connection to the original trilogy could have been achieved by emphasizing the Clone Wars and providing a more seamless transition. Streamlining Episodes: Ditching Episode I: The Phantom Menace, or at least significantly truncating it, could have left room for a more in-depth exploration of the Clone Wars and Anakin's rise to power. Stronger Director: Handing the reins to a new director for the sequels could have improved the storytelling and execution, allowing George Lucas to bow out gracefully rather than facing criticism for direction. Splitting 'Return of the Sith': Breaking Revenge of the Sith into two movies could have provided a more natural pacing for Anakin's fall and the story of the galaxy-spanning civil war.

Conclusion

By addressing these critical areas, the Star Wars prequels might have been more cohesive, nuanced, and engaging. These changes, while difficult to implement in a series with such a large and established fanbase, could have significantly enhanced the trilogy's overall impact and legacy. The prequels, in their current form, suffer from lazy storytelling and underdeveloped characters. With more thoughtful and intricate narrative structures, the Star Wars universe could have been even more rich and complex.