A Brief History of Doctors in Doctor Who: Why They Left and Their Fate

The evolving role of the Doctor in the iconic British science fiction series, Doctor Who, has seen many talented actors take on the iconic character over the decades. Each departure has been unique, marked by various reasons, from health issues to creative differences. This article explores the reasons behind why some Doctors left and what happened to them after their tenure ended.

William Hartnell: Health Issues Led to Invalidment

William Hartnell, the first incarnate Doctor, faced a personal health crisis during his time on the show. He was diagnosed with vascular dementia, a condition that gradually impairs cognitive function. This led to his invalidation after three seasons. Despite his declining health, Hartnell made a poignant return in the 10th anniversary special, though he relied heavily on cue cards as he could no longer remember his lines. The BBC showed admirable respect by editing the episode to preserve his dignity, ensuring his appearance remained meaningful despite his condition.

Patrick Troughton and Jon Pertwee: Typecasting and Early Departures

Patrick Troughton and Jon Pertwee both quit the show after three to four seasons, primarily to avoid suffering from typecasting. Their exits highlight the challenges actors faced in maintaining their diverse acting careers while giving a definitive face to the Doctor. This decision allowed them to pursue other roles and avoid being seen as “only the Doctor,” a common issue faced by actors in similar long-running series.

Tom Baker: Creative Differences and Resignation

Tom Baker's seven-season tenure came to an end thanks to creative differences instigated by the new showrunner, John Nathan-Turner. The conflict between the actors and the production team eventually led to a creative falling out, prompting Baker to resign. His departure marked a significant change in the show's direction and further cemented the idea that the Doctor could be interpreted across different generations.

Peter Davison and Colin Baker: Health and Ratings

Following Troughton’s advice, Peter Davison also stepped down after three seasons, opting for career diversity. Colin Baker, on the other hand, survived two seasons before the show took a hiatus due to falling ratings. Despite casting an all-star cast, the show faced challenges in retaining viewers. Baker was eventually fired, though the movement towards improving scripts and costumes could have played a role in his departure. Not to blame Baker, the scripts he received were reported to be subpar, and the costume, dubbed “daft,” contributed to the issues.

Sylvester McCoy: Forced Departure and Legacy

Sylvester McCoy had his tenure abruptly cut short when the BBC decided to move forward without him. A brief reprisal in the 1996 TV film suggests the decision was made with a return in mind, but sadly, the footage of this incarnation was used to create the final scene of the 2005 reboot, effectively killing off McCoy's Doctor before his time. This abrupt end was a controversial decision and one that fans still debate today.

Paul McGann and David Bradley: Short-Stint Actors

Paul McGann starred in the 1996 TV film but never received a series. He did, however, make several cameo appearances over the years, showcasing his versatility and talents. David Bradley, who not only played the Doctor but also portrayed William Hartnell in special episodes, fared better than many of his predecessors. At 81 years old, he remains an active and respected figure, embodying the resilience and adaptability of the role.

Despite the varying reasons for departure and the diverse actors involved, each Doctor left a lasting impression on the show and its fans. From the pioneering Hercules of the Fourth Doctor to the anarchic antics of the Sixth and Seventh Doctors, and the philosophical explorations of Tom Baker, the series has seen a range of interpretations that have shaped its identity and popularity over the years.

Conclusion

The departure of doctors from the Doctor Who series is often a point of discussion and speculation among fans. Each actor brought unique qualities and interpretations to the role, yet faced different challenges and circumstances leading to their parting. Whether through health issues, creative differences, or changes in the show's direction, the stories of these Doctors are as fascinating as their on-screen adventures.