Why Was Jin Not Included in the Dance Break of the Kinetic Film for ON?
A lot of fans, including myself, are quite upset about the decision to exclude Jin from the dance break of the Kinetic Film for ON. This oversight, which has gone largely unaddressed, strikes at the heart of what it means to be a part of a group, especially one like BTS that has been together for so many years.
Anger and Disappointment
I was genuinely angered by this decision the first time I saw the ON film shortly after its release. While I initially chose not to voice my concerns, the performance at the Grand Central Terminal and the official MV have only fueled my frustration. Not being included in the dance break is not just about the physical aspect; it was a symbolic snub that affected the entire group's representation in the film.
The Neglected Maknae Line
When the Maknae line (youngest members) receives less than half of the song's time or recognition, it often sparks outrage among fans. But when it comes to the Hyung line (older members), especially Jin, the silence is deafening. While many argue that it was Jin's choice not to participate, the emotional impact of this decision is overwhelming. The effort and dedication required to stand together as a unit, especially considering the years they've been working together, make this exclusion even more poignant.
Awe and Understanding of Talent
One perspective suggests that it might be due to Jin's dancing abilities. There is a notion that he is one of the weaker dancers in BTS and that it’s harder for him to look fluid and effortless when dancing. It is also suggested that he does not do many solo dances, and his presence in the group dance is more about blending well rather than showcasing his individual talent. This highlights the dynamic and diverse talents within the group, but also points to the challenges each member faces in performing complex choreographies.
Decisions and Justifications
While many fans defend the decision, pointing to the greater good of the performance, some are frustrated by the justification. People who work hard and put in the effort should also be recognized and included, no matter their skill level. The question remains: why is it harder to champion for a member who has been with the group this long, contributing to their success?
Fan Stan Culture
The discussion also brings up a pertinent point about the culture of fan stans. Fans of BTS are loyal to the group as a whole, with its members and their stories. The decision to exclude Jin from the Kinetic Film is not just a personal slight; it is a broader issue for fans who believe in the group's unity and the importance of each member's contributions. The hashtag #BTSJinJustSang3Lines highlights the collective frustration and disappointment among fans.
Ultimately, the omission of Jin from the dance break in the Kinetic Film for ON is a complex issue that touches on themes of group dynamics, individual talent, and the importance of recognition within a fan community. While it is important to respect individual choices, the collective impact of such decisions is undeniable, and it continues to resonate with many fans.